Page 39 of 41 FirstFirst ... 29 37 38 39 40 41 LastLast
Results 381 to 390 of 407
  1. #381
    Player
    Carighan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Posts
    2,693
    Character
    Carighan Maconar
    World
    Zodiark
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Pixieh View Post
    This is not me dooming, this is me speaking from experiencing it in different games over and over again and being realistic about the vast majority of the playerbase in ANY mmorpg.
    While that's true, you need to keep in mind that FFXIV uniquely doesn't have an actual class role setup of value. Not really. It's the closest to what GW2 did properly, remove tanks/healers/damage as a concept. In FFXIV, only your damage ever matters. So whether Paladin is god or Paladin is trash isn't decided by how good they are as a main tank, offtank or second healer, it's solely decided by whether they deal 2% more or less damage than Bastion. All this split does is ensure that of the two groups of tanks, Paladin/Bastion and Gunbreaker/Darkknight/Warrior, one each will be present in Full Party content, probably. We don't even know whether they'll get them closely-balanced enough for that. Whether a Gunbreaker takes 15% more damage as a main tank has absolutely 0 bearing on how we build parties, if they deal 3% extra damage they'll be the MT instead of a Pally or DW-Pally.

    In a way, this solves a potential issue. Because on paper I agree, this has happened before. But in FFXIV it cannot happen as roles such as tank, or sub-roles such as ranged vs melee DPS, only hold any value when they modify the damage output. Never for their actual role or combat range or anything like that.

    (Regardless of that I enjoy upsides and downsides to classes so big that they're the kings of one type of content while being strictly inferior in others, but I might be showing that even Aion is "too new" for my taste there, I fell in love with CRPGs in older games where the pen&paper heritage was still stronger and hence identity and uniqueness mattered far far far far more than balance capability nevermind actual balance, and being able to do XYZ despite using the inferior setup for it was seen as something cool to do!)
    (2)

  2. #382
    Player
    Terhix's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2021
    Posts
    198
    Character
    Thane Ryder
    World
    Odin
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Pixieh View Post
    (...) Started back in Aion where you had the main tank Templar and the off tank Gladiator. People only wanted 'real' tanks aka the Templar. (...)
    It's been years but this is really apples and oranges, offtank in Aion was semi-dps semi-tank that was kind of bad at being both, that's why people preferred the actual tank. You know what game has offtanks that work as intended? FFXIV, today. Every savage and ultimate static and PF group has a MT and an OT. The only thing an offtank can potentially be worse at in XIV is sustained autos, but it must be on par with MT when it comes to periodical eHP checks else you will just die to some tank busters in ultimates, and even some savage fights (double TB stack in M12S).
    (3)

  3. #383
    Player
    Sunhwapark's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2017
    Posts
    742
    Character
    Delivery Boy
    World
    Phantom
    Main Class
    Monk Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Kishin12345 View Post
    Looking at evolved mode in general it looks like job specific optimization could change a lot or be removed entirely.
    It is a big worry of mine.
    I was playing PLD pre-abyssos savage nerf and them announcing PLD will get its skills hammered in so that it aligns with the 2minute meta.
    After the changes, not really a big fan. I usually played DRK as my tank of choice but now it feels too much like a warrior which I don't enjoy the playstyle of.

    If they remove too much from all the classes without something sufficient or enjoyable in return then doing PvE is pointless for me.
    I hate to feel anxious about the upcoming fanfest because I don't want to be hit with the reality that I and many other people have been alienated from the game after playing for such a while.
    (1)

  4. #384
    Player
    Absurdity's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2018
    Posts
    3,633
    Character
    Tiana Vestoria
    World
    Odin
    Main Class
    Warrior Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Sunhwapark View Post
    If they remove too much from all the classes without something sufficient or enjoyable in return then doing PvE is pointless for me.
    I hate to feel anxious about the upcoming fanfest because I don't want to be hit with the reality that I and many other people have been alienated from the game after playing for such a while.
    Not really anxious anymore, I felt anxious leading up to Shadowbringers when the job previews already looked absolutely awful.

    Shadowbringers was 7 years ago...and it has only gotten worse since.

    Evercold is 4 months away, we know absolutely nothing concrete about Evolved and by the time they'll tell us the Titanic will already be hugging the iceberg.
    If it's going to be the same dogwater gameplay of mindlessly spamming a damage filler while we wait for our burst damage to come off-cooldown, which is just as mindless but with bigger numbers, then we will finally know that they are unwilling and incapable of change, of fixing the problem.
    I will simply switch to Reborn for whatever data collection they're going to do and log out.

    Nothing about the gameplay is actually keeping me subbed, the only thing having me play Dawntrail in the first place was my raid team which has quit in it's entirety.
    I'm sure I can find another game to play with the two friends still keeping me here.
    (2)
    Last edited by Absurdity; 09-17-2026 at 04:35 PM.

  5. #385
    Player
    Carighan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Posts
    2,693
    Character
    Carighan Maconar
    World
    Zodiark
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Sunhwapark View Post
    If they remove too much from all the classes without something sufficient or enjoyable in return then doing PvE is pointless for me.
    To me the route here is pretty obvious, the replacement will be the combat itself. That is, the NPC-side. Dawntrail uses more involved and more complicated mechanics and recombinations of mechanics already, even outside of Extreme/Savage content. Going back into older fights makes this quite noticable how far combat has come.
    Meanwhile, we already had Viper and Picto, which are exactly as non-button-bloat as all classes will be come Evercold. So playing either in one of the newer fights vs another class in an old fight is the after/before comparison here.

    And honestly? Yeah, give me more of that DT fight design! The raids in particular are superb, both in visual and aural, but also in mechanical design and how smart it is done to engage both experienced and new players doing them. It's really really really good. And if reducing the 33 buttons on my hotbar to 12 or so (which I still press in a single, never-changing, sequence that I could trivially bind to a single button I hold down via the official driver of my gamepad mind you, it's that braindead to perform!) allows for even more such design intricacies in Evercold, that's huge win for me.

    Could of course be wrong. But I also play both Viper and Pictomancer, and while I absolutly loathe viper as a design and class (it's such a waste of dev time, even if it was just 5 minutes total which is what its lore and design feel like!), its mechanical implementation and Picto's implementation work well enough, even if Picto is leaps and bounds better than Viper in that regard, too. That's entirely on Viper not daring to be randomized of course, because everything has to be static-rotation-only-no-exceptions.
    And these are two are evolved jobs, in the end. They were the experiment. If everything is like that, that's a huge win.
    (2)

  6. #386
    Player
    Valence's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2018
    Posts
    6,025
    Character
    Sunie Mochi
    World
    Twintania
    Main Class
    Machinist Lv 100
    So you're essentially for the entire removal of job intricacies and in favor of the entire game based on encounter design, or what did I understand poorly here?
    (1)

  7. #387
    Player
    Absurdity's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2018
    Posts
    3,633
    Character
    Tiana Vestoria
    World
    Odin
    Main Class
    Warrior Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Valence View Post
    So you're essentially for the entire removal of job intricacies and in favor of the entire game based on encounter design, or what did I understand poorly here?
    Sure sounds like it.
    But it's pretty in-line with Carighan's overarching opinion on XIV job. Because it's already as shallow as a puddle, and job intricacies pretty much don't exist anymore, you might as well trim that down to it's most basic components.

    Just something we're fundamentally disagreeing on.
    Making job gameplay even more basic and pumping everything into fight design is not going to save the combat.

    Dawntrail has already tried this, dungeons are still a boring chore with the same copy+paste design, normal raids remain a joke, alliance raids have their mechanics skipped in the same patch they're released.

    Sure, the mechanics are slightly faster, but they're still the same mechanics we've dealt with for over a decade. Making me dodge a line AoE in 2 seconds instead of 3 is not going to blow my socks off.
    (2)

  8. #388
    Player
    Carighan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Posts
    2,693
    Character
    Carighan Maconar
    World
    Zodiark
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Valence View Post
    So you're essentially for the entire removal of job intricacies and in favor of the entire game based on encounter design, or what did I understand poorly here?
    I'd prefer intricate class designs, definitely. In particular, I prefer class designs that want to actually designate a class. As in, giving you unique strengths, but also weaknesses.

    Like Absurdity says, as the current classes from my perspective lack such a design entirely and also already provide ~no gameplay value as they're all a fully static rotation - something usually done singularly as a counterpoint to all the other classes not doing it (because of how boring it becomes once muscle memory sets in) - I see no reason to keep them as they are.

    This is difficult to truly explain how it seems from my perspective without sounding like I just hate the game (I don't, I love it, but I think it could do so much more with so much less when it comes to classes and combat), maybe a microcosm example:

    Tank CDs
    Why do we have so many? Why do we all have a 20% CD, a 40% CD and an invuln? Plus our short CD and our "extra" CD? These are all shared concepts, so they do not give any one tank something peculiar the others do not get. All the actual class identity is in the differences so why don't we keep only those?

    After all, the game more or less expects you to press defensive button A in reaction to combat event 1 and buttons B+C in reaction to combat event 2. That's just a QTE. This can be fun as a "Phew, job well done"-thing, but it also doesn't give players agency. You either do it, well, it's done. Or you don't, in which case you caused a wipe for no reason. An even more egregious sub-element of this is how often we are expected to press two CDs are once, instead of the functionality being just one button to begin with. That's just finger-busywork in the end.

    So I would do:
    * I'd remove all the "shared" elements, and tune combat so that the existing fixed "Please press button X"-checks are just removed. Push way way way more baseline damage via autoattacks and such, rause base defenses to compensate if needed but should not, healers will be happy they got something to use their heals on for once.
    * Keep say, only two defensive CDs per tank. At least one ought to be avaiable on a very short CD. Less CDs, but more readily available > many CDs, but with huge CDs. There might be a tank with only 1 or maybe 3, or maybe one tank has a defensive setup that's 1 CD + 1 passive effect the others have no equivalence for.
    * Make these highly unique. You know what? Only Paladin has an invuln! Yes, that can be balanced. Want an invuln, play a Paladin!
    * Meanwhile, maybe warrior has a way higher health pool due to a trait, but flat out has no defensive CDs. Their CDs are exclusively about healing themselves. But they survive from more raw HP.
    (and so on, and that's just a very rough and not at all thought out example for how I think about it - there is no reason to have 10 buttons all just doing <some> potency either, make it 1 button)
    (1)
    Last edited by Carighan; 09-18-2026 at 12:43 AM.

  9. #389
    Player
    Pixieh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2021
    Posts
    89
    Character
    Unhinged Gremlin
    World
    Lamia
    Main Class
    Gunbreaker Lv 100
    The entire point is that it should be a players choice whether to be that main tank or off tank.

    SE is taking that choice from us. Taking away player choice like that is never okay and is just absolutely horrendous design. Period. Full stop.
    (2)

  10. #390
    Player
    Carighan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Posts
    2,693
    Character
    Carighan Maconar
    World
    Zodiark
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Pixieh View Post
    The entire point is that it should be a players choice whether to be that main tank or off tank.

    SE is taking that choice from us. Taking away player choice like that is never okay and is just absolutely horrendous design. Period. Full stop.
    I can only sum up my objection to this with the usual: [citation needed]
    Where does it say that it should be the player's choice?

    Or more specifically, how does that map to any class-based situation? Should it be a Dragoon's choice to play from range, despite being a melee DPS? They can mind you, they'll just be terrible at it, far worse than an OT will be at MTing from all we know. Should it be a White Mage's choice to exclusively cast shields this time, and take the shield healer spot?

    Now of course, why this is different is because it happens later. But that is more on FFXIV's static development, because other ongoing games experiment far more and far more frequently with sweeping changes. For a common example, look at WoW flat-out making only one of three Death Knight specs a tank, instead of any of the three as originally built. Look at DAoC keeping nothing but the name of the Necromancer class, ripping out the entire design of it and replacing it. Granted they near-total-reimplementations with a lot of classes but that's the one time I can readily point at where they flat out deleted a class and brought in another one under the previous name.

    My point being: That's not really a doom&gloom argument. Quite the opposite, that genuinely sounds positive. Classes require specialization to not be pointless. Like I said before, I fault the new setup (MT vs OT) for bringin only two specializations, that particular MT vs OT. I want five. I want each of the tanks to be strictly superior at some things, being clearly the best tank for that job, and inferior at others, able to do it but you wouldn't want to if someone else is there to do it instead. I don't know which five specialisations I could point at in the context of FFXIV's combat (this game has too many classes for its own good...) so I kinda get only doing two specs, but I would prefer actual per-class-strengths.

    So to me this is a step in the right direction. It's not enough, in particular because we already have this split, it's just informal right now and SQEX is formalizing it. But it's still a step in the right direction, showing the devs willing to add more specialization into classes instead of continously removing that and making all classes functionally identical which is what they usually do.
    (2)

Page 39 of 41 FirstFirst ... 29 37 38 39 40 41 LastLast