Page 37 of 41 FirstFirst ... 27 35 36 37 38 39 ... LastLast
Results 361 to 370 of 407
  1. #361
    Player
    Lyth's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2015
    Location
    Meracydia
    Posts
    3,918
    Character
    Lythia Norvaine
    World
    Gilgamesh
    Main Class
    Beastmaster Lv 50
    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    So, easy balance:
    * MTs deal 95% damage.
    * To get that missing 5%, they need to be actively attacked.
    * OTs deal 100% damage.
    * However, they lose 5% of that damage when they engage their active self-protection continuously.
    If players saw this on release, they'd just lock out main tanks entirely and run two off-tanks on swaps/invulns. If the off tanks take more damage as a result, then the expectation will be that the healers will sort it out.

    I'm reminded of Stormblood's tank accessory fiasco. The dev team wanted tanks to stop using STR accessories, so they role locked the new accessories and made them VIT only (such that tank accessories didn't provide meaningful damage progression). Tanks went back to the previous expansion's STR accessories (i270) and used them instead, while making their healers cross-compensate for the loss of eHP. They backtracked pretty much immediately.

    That being said, I would be surprised if counters make up a large portion of main tank damage, because the devs are averse to penalizing players for rotational mistakes (such as missing counters or not planning for them). But even a small dps imbalance between the subroles can be enough for players to start enforcing double main tank or double off tank setups, if there's not enough of a difference between the subroles outside of that.

    I think that if you want this role split to work, it needs to be through mitigation/utility. If a particular job provides a simpler way of solving a mechanic, then you'll still want to take that job regardless of small dps variations between jobs. Give players a reason to want to run one of each subrole, rather than trying to force them to play this way.
    (2)

  2. #362
    Player
    Carighan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Posts
    2,693
    Character
    Carighan Maconar
    World
    Zodiark
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Yeah but like I said, as absurd as that 4-point-scenario is, that's how I expect them to do it. All other implementations beyond simple hardlocked (and I'm excluding that for a moment, even though I know it's a solution GW2 also uses in some fights by just forcibly aggroing the boss onto the tank no matter what, since the game has no inherent threat generation systems) aggro wouldn't work, as we as players would naturally not care.

    So there's two scenarios: Either the tanks are of different strengths at tanking. This is good for everyone who is worried, because it means factually not a single player will care who MTs and who OTs. You can do whatever, as we can be ~100% sure tank strength will still never be tested on a tanking level in Evercold, either. And yes, this is probably the idea lsolution we can hope for still, even if it ends up being factually meaningless.

    Alternatively, they implement something counterpart to the shown MT counterattack, so that both tank types only do their maximum damage when in their respective slots. And as plenty have commented now ,that's kinda... not good. But then again we also know that damage is the only thing they can ever push us the playerbase with in FFXIV, as it is the only metric that's worth anything.

    And sure, in theory it could be that all 5 tanks end up functionally different. Third solution. And it just so happens that the wildly divergent kits are so that only BST and PLD are truly amazing at facing the boss, while GNB, DRK and WAR are amazing when protecting the group, not themselves. Could be. Chances of that? Yeah that's no from me, sorry. I'll believe it ~3 months after I see and it hasn't been patched out again quickly. It'll end up being damage-balanced. It always does, in this game.
    (0)

  3. #363
    Player
    Miki_L's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2023
    Posts
    78
    Character
    Miki Loire
    World
    Midgardsormr
    Main Class
    Gunbreaker Lv 100
    The only way I think this can work is by having a mandatory party mit/aura that does not stack between off tanks that is pretty much required in savage+ content to not instantly die to raidwides. Then you would have to give main tanks naturally more damage to make people feel obligated bring one. Although then it would feel weird that the most heavily armored tanks are doing more damage than the ones wielding two handed weapons…

    It cannot be enforced by having marginally better party/self mitigation because then it will just simply be a healer issue to solve. Got two off tanks and a hard hitting buster coming up? No problem. Our healers are sitting on spare ogcds that have no other place to use because healers aren’t ever intended to use all of their abilities. Got two main tanks? Just use an extra gcd heal for safety and we will be fine.

    The level of tanking on average has deteriorated that I don’t trust the developers to just suddenly make them think about anything on short notice. They didn’t them to handle enmity, move and face the boss…

    How many times do squishy dps die to raidwides while the tanks both have their short party mits off cooldown? It really should be standard for phys range to always be mitted on a magic raidwides.
    (0)

  4. #364
    Player
    TouchandFeel's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2013
    Posts
    1,847
    Character
    Kharis Kuraokami
    World
    Exodus
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 91
    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    And speaking of which, have you considered that that is how they'll balance "main" vs "off" tank? By damage? Because sadly, in FFXIV damage reigns 100% supreme even for non-damage classes. It's not like in other games where it is also important, it is the only relevant metric at all here.

    So, easy balance:
    * MTs deal 95% damage.
    * To get that missing 5%, they need to be actively attacked.
    * OTs deal 100% damage.
    * However, they lose 5% of that damage when they engage their active self-protection continuously.

    Done, MT/OT split entirely via damage. That'd be a terrible idea in any other MMO where tank balance relies on tank parameters, but it could be done here.
    I feel that it may be similar to this but with a few small but important distinctions.

    First, the most controversial one, MTs doing less damage unless being actively attacked.
    Where I think this will land is that the MT will do a base-line slightly lower amount of damage in their standard rotation and that the extra amount of damage to put them on par will be done via their "Counter-attack" mechanic, which they will be able to do in either tank position as long as they are getting directly hit or the party member they are protecting with whatever ability, like Protect, is getting hit.
    So, in order to do their full potential damage MTs will have to actively be defending themselves or another.
    To counteract this extra effort for the counter-attacks, their base damage rotation may be a little more simple to give them a bit more breathing room to focus on the counter-attack mechanic.

    Now about the OTs doing full damage normally but losing damage by using their personal defensives.
    I don't feel that OTs will loose any damage, they will just have their full damage potential within their standard rotation of weapon-skills and offensive abilities. However, to counter-balance against the way MTs play offensively, the OTs will likely have a slightly more involved offensive rotation. Essentially, instead of having the "counter-attack" mechanic, the OTs will have something within their own job kit that adds that extra bit of effort and complexity to do damage.
    The new "OT" specific function that is more active will likely be something on the defensive/utility side based on what was on that slide, where they are having to apply debuffs to lower enemy damage. How exactly the mechanics will work around triggering and being able to use these debuff abilities has yet to be shown, but I really hope it is something more interesting than just being on a timer.
    With that debuff mechanic for OTs, that could likely mean that their base defensive kit is a little weaker than the MT and to reach full defensive capabilities they have to be executing the debuff mechanic regularly similar to how MTs have to be doing their counter-attacks to reach full offensive capability.

    So, overall I don't think we will really see a split in full damage or defense capabilities and both MT and OT will be able to perform fairly equitably offensively or defensively while either MTing or OTing, they will just do it slightly differently.
    The main split looks like it will be around party utility, with both roles having some base-line amount of both single-target and party-wide utility but then MT having a little extra single-target defense/buff mechanic and OT having a little more party-wide defense via debuffing.
    Conceptually, you could think of MT as feeling more defensive while OT is the more aggressive feeling one.

    I could of course be completely wrong and it ends up how you say or a vastly different implementation, but this is what to me seems would make the most sense for implementation based on what the devs have said and shown so far.
    (2)
    Last edited by TouchandFeel; 09-09-2026 at 08:06 AM.

  5. #365
    Player
    Mikey_R's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    1,816
    Character
    Mike Aettir
    World
    Cerberus
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Kishin12345 View Post
    There will be a new mechanic requiring a mt and ot in savage and ultimate difficulty. You are forced to bring either bastion or paladin. Takes away flexibility and player choice.
    Except, that is wrong. What was explicitly stated was that it would be more efficient to clear content by bringing one of each as stated in the dev panel.

    Quote Originally Posted by Kishin12345 View Post
    I remember back in hw the devs wanted pld to mt anfd it was just bad and pld never got played.
    That was down to a couple of factors, one, PLD was the lowest on the tank DPS by quite a bit and two, the magority of damage from any encounter that mattered, ie. Savage, the vast majority of it was magic damage, which PLD was just bad at mitigating.

    Both of these issues have been addressed since then and I doubt they are going to go back to this era of imbalance.

    Quote Originally Posted by Kishin12345 View Post
    Then again i could see them do that now that there are no buffs left in the game. How could you validate dnc dealing as much damage as a sam for example?
    If you jus take Dancer's Standard Finish buff, that will be enough. Something that you need to keep up 100% of the time by maintaining your rotation. Remember, the issue isn't that you can buff other players, it is the fact you can buff other players in a limited window. By having a buff up 100% of the time, it doesn't change how the receiver does their rotation. I would also add that you would necessarily need to make a change so that you cannot switch dance partners during combat, otherwise you can end with a situation where the dance partner shifts around the party as people burst, which is, again, not what they are going for.

    Quote Originally Posted by Pixieh View Post
    Like I said before. It does NOT matter what the change actually means because at the end of the day, the vast majority of the playerbase will only see the labels. They won't care about the details. They will see Main Tank and Off Tank and judge tanks by that. It really is that simple.
    And you don't think the playerbase will adapt around the potentially weird naming convention when they realise what it actually entails? What if OT turns out to have a fun mechanic, would that still push people away, just because of a name?
    (0)

  6. #366
    Player
    Kishin12345's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2025
    Posts
    190
    Character
    Eldin Valesk
    World
    Lich
    Main Class
    Dragoon Lv 60
    Quote Originally Posted by Mikey_R View Post
    Except, that is wrong. What was explicitly stated was that it would be more efficient to clear content by bringing one of each as stated in the dev panel.
    No it is stated in the newest famitsu interview that you will require a mt and ot because of a new mechanic that enforces the split in savage and higher difficulty.
    The interview came out after the fan fest. There is also the new info about Bastion's kardia sticker and people being worried about the whole tank split thing.
    (1)

  7. #367
    Player
    Mikey_R's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    1,816
    Character
    Mike Aettir
    World
    Cerberus
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Kishin12345 View Post
    No it is stated in the newest famitsu interview that you will require a mt and ot because of a new mechanic that enforces the split in savage and higher difficulty.
    The interview came out after the fan fest. There is also the new info about Bastion's kardia sticker and people being worried about the whole tank split thing.
    I think I have found the right interview, took me a while, however, what I will say is, are you relying on Google translate to translate the page to get your information? With note that things translated in this way should be taken with a grain of salt, I think the word used in the translation was 'necessary'.

    Now, the question is, are you going to trust that Google translate has the wording 100% right, or, are you going to trust the live translation from Koji Fox, who speaks both languages and will more accurately translate what was said?

    I think, unless someone who is capable of speaking Japanese and can translate directly what the famitsu interview said (and, if necessary explain any ambiguity that could arise from said translation) I think I would rather go with what was officially translated for now.

    Not to mention that Reborn mode doesn't have the MT/OT distinction, so you cannot have content that requires an MT/OT, otherwise, you are making a tanks reborn mode completely useless and Savage+, which they also do not want to do.
    (0)

  8. #368
    Player
    Azurarok's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2022
    Posts
    1,590
    Character
    Medim Azurarok
    World
    Siren
    Main Class
    Machinist Lv 100
    Guessing the part in question is this bit:
    ――『白銀のワンダラー』ではタンクロールがメインタンクとサブタンクにより明確に分けられると聞きました。この役割分担はどの程度厳密になるのでしょうか? エオルゼア中の戦士はサブタンクの勉強を始めるべきでしょうか?

    吉田:「戦士はサブタンクの勉強をしたほうがいいですか」というのは、少し心が痛いのですが……。暗黒騎士をプレイされている方からも同じような声はいただいているものの、エヴォルヴモードではどちらかがメインタンク、もう一方はサブタンクと決めて調整をしていかなければいけません。もちろん、サブタンクならではの楽しさをちゃんと作ってありますので、そこはポジティブに楽しみにしておいていただけるとうれしいです。

     ただ、いまから何かを予習したり、気構えたりする必要はないと思っています。このシステムがスタートするのは8.0からになり、メインタンク・サブタンクの役割が明確に必要になってくるのは、零式以上の難度のコンテンツからになります。そのレイドでは、このシステムを活かした新しいバトルのギミックもしっかりと作っていきます。それを見てから話し合ってプレイしてもらったほうが絶対に楽しいと思いますので、いまから何かを練習しておかなくてもいいのではないかなと思っています。
    Which I'd translate to:
    I heard the tank role is going to be split to Main Tank and Off Tanks. How strictly is this split going to be enforced? Do Warriors need to start studying to become off tanks?

    Yoshida: It pains me a little to be asked if "Warriors need to study to become off tanks".... I got similar questions from Dark Knights as well, and with Evolved mode, we will have to adjust the jobs based on whether one is a Main Tank or an Off Tank. Now, we intend to make unique gameplay mechanics for Off Tanks of course, so please look forward to that.

    At any rate, there shouldn't be any need to prepare for it just yet. This system starts in 8.0, and the designations as MT and OT should only be enforced in Savage difficulty and higher. We intend to make full use of the new system there. I believe it will be much more enjoyable to figure things out after seeing it, so I don't think there's any need for practice anything now.
    (1)

  9. #369
    Player
    Kishin12345's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2025
    Posts
    190
    Character
    Eldin Valesk
    World
    Lich
    Main Class
    Dragoon Lv 60
    Quote Originally Posted by Mikey_R View Post
    I think I have found the right interview, took me a while, however, what I will say is, are you relying on Google translate to translate the page to get your information? With note that things translated in this way should be taken with a grain of salt, I think the word used in the translation was 'necessary'.

    Now, the question is, are you going to trust that Google translate has the wording 100% right, or, are you going to trust the live translation from Koji Fox, who speaks both languages and will more accurately translate what was said?

    I think, unless someone who is capable of speaking Japanese and can translate directly what the famitsu interview said (and, if necessary explain any ambiguity that could arise from said translation) I think I would rather go with what was officially translated for now.

    Not to mention that Reborn mode doesn't have the MT/OT distinction, so you cannot have content that requires an MT/OT, otherwise, you are making a tanks reborn mode completely useless and Savage+, which they also do not want to do.
    If you can speak japanese it translates to mandatory or enforced.
    But thinking about it, it cant just be a tb that needs to be countered since in reborn mode the tanks dont have that.
    It could be that it is a tankbuster that needs to be invuln'd and in evolved only ots don't have invulns anymore?
    That could be a thing that only mt has invulns and the special tb would just 1 shot no matter how much mitigation is used.

    And keep in mind, that interview got released after the fan fest. So at the fan fest they might have been more careful with the wording. Or translation mistakes happened again.
    (0)
    Last edited by Kishin12345; 09-13-2026 at 08:27 AM.

  10. 09-13-2026 10:12 AM

  11. #370
    Player
    Mikey_R's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    1,816
    Character
    Mike Aettir
    World
    Cerberus
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Kishin12345 View Post
    If you can speak japanese it translates to mandatory or enforced.
    Just to note that context matters and picking out specific words doesn't mean much. I mean, in English, if we call something inflammable, it can either be easily set alight, or, uncapable of being set alight. 2 opposite meanings, same word.

    Going from the translation Azurarok provided:

    and the designations as MT and OT should only be enforced in Savage difficulty and higher. We intend to make full use of the new system there.
    Should only does a lot of heavy lifting. 'Should only be enforced in savage' can imply it might be relevant in a savage fight, but it could also mean things might appear in extreme fights or below as well. The next sentence does imply it is being limited to Savage and above however, (plus, with everything that has been said by the devs), which is another example of why context matters.

    Another thing to note is that, do we know that what is in the article is exactly what Yoshi said, or, was there a bit of creative freedom in how it was put to page. I only say this because I did come across 3 English interviews (on something different) where it was clear all 3 were in the room at the same time as the same questions were asked, but they all gave slightly different responses with the same or similar meaning. I don't know how accurate Famitsu is at writing down answers but there is also that possibility (however, I'm not going to mark this against anything).

    Bottom line is there are many variables at play here, not least of all, we have no idea how OTs play or how fights are going to be structured, so there is no point fearing for the worst, or even the best, based on nothing. We need more info.

    Quote Originally Posted by Kishin12345 View Post
    But thinking about it, it cant just be a tb that needs to be countered since in reborn mode the tanks dont have that.
    It could be that it is a tankbuster that needs to be invuln'd and in evolved only ots don't have invulns anymore?
    That could be a thing that only mt has invulns and the special tb would just 1 shot no matter how much mitigation is used.
    And for Warrior, Dark Knight and Gunbreaker Reborn mode? Are they losing invuns as well? Pretty sure their aim was to keep tanks still playing fairly similar, so getting rid of invulns is going to be massive change to gameplay. And that is the thing, Reborn is always going to be a thorn in the side for the MT/OT split and we don't know how much they are going to be changing them, specially since they do not have an MT/OT split and this is confirmed by the same interview that says MT/OT is necessary or required. You cannot have it both ways.

    Quote Originally Posted by Kishin12345 View Post
    And keep in mind, that interview got released after the fan fest. So at the fan fest they might have been more careful with the wording. Or translation mistakes happened again.
    Without knowing how they done the interview, did they take notes or record the interview before making the article, it can mean things could get lost or misinterpreted, even if everything was done in the same language. It happens in English all the time and I see no reason why wouldn't happen in Japanese either.
    (0)

Page 37 of 41 FirstFirst ... 27 35 36 37 38 39 ... LastLast