Results -9 to 0 of 409

Threaded View

  1. #10
    Player
    Sazuzaki's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2021
    Location
    Ul'Dah
    Posts
    220
    Character
    Sazu Velgr
    World
    Jenova
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    I appreciate you dropping a link to that video. 20 minutes in and it's very interesting, so here's my take on it:

    I get what you mean by saying pairing DPS with Holy Sheltron is a cursed problem; the problem arising from having to use Holy Sheltron as often as possible to maximize damage rather than holding it for when it counts. But here's the thing: Holy Sheltron has two charges on a 20 second CD. One charge is used to mitigate auto-attacks consistently, the other charge is held for TBs and the like. So long as you never overcap and you end the fight with no charges, you didn't lose DPS due to not spamming Holy Sheltron. The key design factor here is that having Holy Sheltron at two charges makes it to where you won't overcap so long as you keep the CD running with 1 charge open for flexibility. That directly addresses the cursed problem regarding attaching damage to mitigation.

    In the case of gap closers, that actually wasn't the reality. Yes you would use them for damage, but most of the time it was more of a DPS loss to use it for burst than where you would otherwise need it. I can see why people didn't like using Plunge during a burst, but you actually got less damage if you consistently used Plunge purely during a burst than if you held a charge for maintaining uptime. Plunge's optimization was just use it during burst if you aren't going to use it anywhere else. I can see how this represents a cursed problem since the main draw is the gap closing, but it boiled down to how you managed its use.

    The main thing with the cursed problems we have in XIV right now is that they're inherently subjective and unsolvable. Using GNB's continuation for example, continuation makes it much harder for GNB to weave in defensives, yet people love it. It's creates a "cursed problem" for a tank because it must have room to weave in defensives yet GNB's continuation goes against it. It's here because most people like Continuation for what it is and don't mind the friction it presents.

    Alex mentions how cursed problems require giving up a part of the original idea, and that's pretty much what they're doing with the current tank design: they're giving up on the idea that all tanks need to be good at the same things in hope to improve job identity. Whether you think the idea is good or not is up for debate, but I think it's important to keep in mind that because you think something may introduce a cursed problem doesn't exactly mean it's a bad idea. If something is fun and can be worked around, I think it deserves to stay in the game.
    (1)
    Last edited by Sazuzaki; 05-21-2026 at 06:13 AM. Reason: typos