Galka to Roegadyn had the most drastic change from original to modified for FFXIV races. The change in arm and leg length. Missing tail. Less pronounced fur. Between all the Character Races it is the very least like its progenitor. Mobs and NPC's do not matter as much because they do change between titles quite often and look different each time. We're talking about Races which were copied for the sole purpose of making their FFXI players feel at home. For Galka players, we do not.
So far all the complaints I've heard about tails is, "BUT TEH SU ULGIY!"
Galka players liked how they looked and we would like the ability to continue our Fantasy into this new title like everyone else. I advocate the option of tails in character creation so those who prefer the newer tail-less look won't have anything thrust upon them.
It doesn't matter how people to try to convolute the concept.
Galka = Roegadyn
Different name, different game, same race.