Quote Originally Posted by AmiableApkallu View Post
(emphasis mine)

I want to have to think which button I should push next, actually.

"Shiny" is all good an well, but I can get that just by watching a movie or TV show. A game should make me think (or test my reflexes, or something).
Honestly, none of the jobs require any kind of thought. It's all memorizing and executing a rotation, some are just easier to memorize than others.