Honestly I see the logic behind your point but I think the culture is too set on PF, which is what I would prefer anyway. I've given up entirely on clearing the chaotic due to just how difficult it is to get a full PF as well as one that isn't prog lying or doesn't have someone who rage quits after 2 wipes, Maybe if I can find a discord server for it or something. Anyways, I think the downsides of the Raid Finder outweigh the downsides of PF. PF You can at least be (relatively) certain everyone will be using a specific strategy or guide. DF people might be split on what one to use or come into disagreements on what role they want. I think RF would have even more selfish people expecting to get carried or people who are genuinely just clueless to what kind of content Chaotic is. I think the control you have over who is in your group in PF (keeping certain players out, i.e people you've black listed) makes up for the negatives there are.