Questionable ethics - Living Memory

[CNitsah]

How can you be a copy of a human being and not be able to make new choices? What are you talking about?

Only thing divided imo is people trolling and people who just took the story for what it is.

Sorry if it's dismissive but the "this isn't philosophical enough for me" kinda falls flat when you don't really make any sense to begin with.

And I mean that seriously. At what point are you a copy of the person do you become unable to use your brain??? Why would Sphene even invent that kind of system?

I don't know how you got that from my message. I'm not saying this is not philosophical enough for me.
I'm saying that the eternals basically ask the question "what does it mean to be alive" (or more accurately, "what are the limits of being alive"), which is a question that has been there for hundreds, even thousands of years, with no definitive answers. Then FFXIV gave a simple answer. If your personnal belief align with that answer given in DT and you consider that the endless don't meet the requirements to be considered alive, you will not have any problem with it. If you consider they do meet the requirement, you will have problems with the way DT treated them.

I'm not giving a solution, I'm explaining why both vision have their arguments, and why there will never be any consensus on that kind of question.