M4S has officially been beaten without healers in week 2

[Raven2014]

Wasn't their a fight last expansion that was over tuned and people got upset over it? Wasn't it tge ultimate fight? We really are a community that cannot be pleased short from pure perfection.

uh ... if you go to the restaurant and order a dish:

- If it comes out raw, you should complain.

- If it comes out burn, you should also complain.

- I don't think asking for your good to be cook right is asking too much, do you?

I don't think the "people can't seem make up their mind" argument will work here.

[Bobby66]

uh ... if you go to the restaurant and order a dish:

- If it comes out raw, you should complain.

- If it comes out burn, you should also complain.

- I don't think asking for your good to be cook right is asking too much, do you?

I don't think the "people can't seem make up their mind" argument will work here.

This is not a restaurant this is about trying to strike a balance when with vastly differing views on what is best. That is not exactly an easy task and someone will always get the short end of the straw. Case in point old SMN. I and a I am sure many others enjoyed it, but it was altered to legit become one of the easiest classes in the game.

Unlike a restaurant things are not made to order in an MMO. MMO is more of a buffet.

I doubt anyone is expecting perfect balance. In fact, there's been more and more people asking for fun jobs over perfect balance.

What most people want is just for their job to be viable, it's only a very fringe group that wants their preferred job to be meta all the time.

As for why they didn't just ask people to play a different job or wait for gear? It's because they're trying to craft an image of every job being viable, so instead of going through all 19 jobs at the time to rebalance them and make sure every comp can clear the fight, it's far easier to just nerf the HP of the fight.

It was a rhetorical question. That is my point is SE appears to want to maintain this design philosophy instead of just telling people maybe certain jobs are just not meant for them try one of the other flavors they are like let us make sure everything can enjoy every flavor. Bad analogy but I am sure you get the point. That is why I do not think they will ever do much to change because they seem to want everything to be accessible to everyone but everyone has a differing view of what is accessible.