Being punished with a worse song is still a fail state
If they made this song say “x echo” where it replays the song for half the effect, half the buff and half the proc chance you are still being heavily punished for dying but it doesn’t completely ruin your song rotation for like half the rest of the fight
Fail states are good, fail states that functionally can’t be fully corrected even with time are bad, even BLM you can fix it’s fail state by simply returning to ice and starting again