Role Quest Ranking and Review (Spoilers)

[Allegor]

My honest opinion is that, just like with the EW quests, it feels they focused on making a questline first, and add the role supposed to do said questline last. Aside from very niche "identities" glued on to explain why they need someone of certain role specifically, really any role should be able to do any of those quests. For example, the healer one needing you to Esuna all the time but then the quest itself says just about anyone with an antidote could heal the poisons, so you being a healer is redundant when you could as well be a NIN carrying some potions. At no point do you actually need to heal anyone.

[GrizzlyTank]

My honest opinion is that, just like with the EW quests, it feels they focused on making a questline first, and add the role supposed to do said questline last. Aside from very niche "identities" glued on to explain why they need someone of certain role specifically, really any role should be able to do any of those quests. For example, the healer one needing you to Esuna all the time but then the quest itself says just about anyone with an antidote could heal the poisons, so you being a healer is redundant when you could as well be a NIN carrying some potions. At no point do you actually need to heal anyone.

Feels like the EW ones should have been held back until you hit the point where ragnarock had to be fixed. And then used the job questline as a breather to check out the other city states and return to a ready space-ship.