Wow, Wuk Lamat is really single-handedly ruining the DT story...

[Midare]

Please don't screw Poochie. The last thing we need is mini Wuk Lamats.

Part of me is glad that I wasn't the only one who caught on that...

And the other got sad because I caught on that.

[arstoka]

What I would give for another Bloody Banquet...

Tural could have been really interesting with the new people and cultures and possible dynamics. Peace is great and all but when everything is working near "perfectly" it leads to a very dull world of hand holding and singing campfire songs.

I'd have been nice if they drew upon more real world situations and historical events and just...how people interact with each other. It would have been nice to see people talk about the biggest political event in the last 80 years with more nuance. Have some in-fighting, have groups openly disagree with some of the candidates out in the open world. It would have made it feel a lot more connected to what was going on.

But again...this is all fan fiction and wishful thinking.

[Maxilor]

Please don't screw Poochie. The last thing we need is mini Wuk Lamats.

[ZXN]

The sad thing is that I really believe Wuk could've been an interesting character with some good development and story. Unfortunately, for me personally anyway, the story presented Wuk Lamat as a "Black Hole Sue" of sorts from start to finish.

Even if, as some people say, "Dawntrail is Wuk Lamat's expansion and story", many of the situations and confrontations that occur are presented very specifically to accommodate and reward Wuk's specific actions/way of thinking, with most resulting in "perfect" resolutions and outcomes always in her favor.

As much as I love my boy Bakool Ja Ja, you're not going to convince me that after kidnapping Wuk to take her keystone, releasing Valigarmanda for literally no reason other then essentially "because I can", and literally saying that Wuk's birth father was going to be killed after Wuk loses in 1 on 1 combat against him, alongside some other basic villain things like pulling his weapons out against civilians to strike them down and constantly blocking the feat paths, that after just a few bonks on the heads with an axe, one sad story that our WoL LITERALLY says to not use as an excuse for what he's done, and ONE short heart to heart talk with Wuk, they are now friends and everyone around just goes "Okay, he's forgiven." The fact Alisaie even says "Well, maybe it's for the best. Hatred is exhausting, after all" right after along with Wuk saying all her anger just disappeared effortlessly caused me some bad whiplash at how insanely sudden the 180 was both done and resolved with an absolutely perfect outcome.

I will say though, overall, I really did enjoy Dawntrail. Once I quickly figured out early on to turn my brain off when it came to Wuk Lamat in anyway.

[BabySneed]

I will say though, overall, I really did enjoy Dawntrail. Once I quickly figured out early on to turn my brain off when it came to Wuk Lamat in anyway.

Someone needs to make "Dawntrail Without Wuk Lamat" ala Garfield Without Garfield, if for no other reason I really want to see how much shorter it would be

[SteakDriven]

I'll give Hiroi credit: the *idea* of two groups who are both 'right' coming into conflict is great.

He just... there's a level beyond screwing the pooch I apparently didn't know about.

I consider the concept pretentious.

[royox]

Someone needs to make "Dawntrail Without Wuk Lamat" ala Garfield Without Garfield, if for no other reason I really want to see how much shorter it would be

Now that you said it, I thought about it and It would be an amazing story.

MSQ would start with one of the grand companies receiving an S.O.S call from Tural asking for help against an "invader not from this world" (Maybe Erenville himself sends the message). We would arrive there when the "Dome" is already set and start building a counter-strike army. For that we visit 1 by 1 the Tural tribes, do some favours and in echange they have to help us fight against the invaders. Then we enter inside of the Dome with the Scions and the rest of the story would be more or less the same but without Wuk Lamat WukLamating every scene.

[Remember_The_Name]

What a great thread to read. Good to see so many people dissappointed with Wuk Lamat and Dawntral MSQ in general.

I have a lot of thoughts to post here, but there is one particular one gnawing at my mind:

Tural is like... more than twice the size of Eorzea. And so far we didn't saw ANY signs of Ascian influence in this region. Not a single note.

Through the expansions it was revealed that Ascians messed up with pretty much every beast tribe they encountered. To sow unrest, cause conflicts and set up the Source for another Rejoining.

I cannot believe that such "fertile" land as Tural with its many tribes and nations that are not aware to their danger was ignored by them. Why these two huge continents has no long lasting problems whatsoever?! (Oh, Mamool Ja problem apparently wasn't one, because Wuk solved it in 5 minutes or so)

[LisseyCrowe]

What a great thread to read. Good to see so many people dissappointed with Wuk Lamat and Dawntral MSQ in general.

I have a lot of thoughts to post here, but there is one particular one gnawing at my mind:

Tural is like... more than twice the size of Eorzea. And so far we didn't saw ANY signs of Ascian influence in this region. Not a single note.

Through the expansions it was revealed that Ascians messed up with pretty much every beast tribe they encountered. To sow unrest, cause conflicts and set up the Source for another Rejoining.

I cannot believe that such "fertile" land as Tural with its many tribes and nations that are not aware to their danger was ignored by them. Why these two huge continents has no long lasting problems whatsoever?! (Oh, Mamool Ja problem apparently wasn't one, because Wuk solved it in 5 minutes or so)

I'm not sure but the Tural races might be too young? It's hard to say for sure because DT's world-building is absent. In one of the crafter quests you go through short fables from each race and it seems many might origin from Eorzea. Add to that how Gulool Ja Ja mostly connected the races rather than fought them for dominance.

It's still something I'd have liked to see explained more directly but that's a common theme across the expansion: Minimal world-building built for the sole purpose of whatever's happening in the plot right now.

[Raven2014]

I really wished they would start to learn to tell another story.

All writers are bad with that, even Ishikawa.
No evil nation leader allowed anymore and now with Garlemald gone there is no grey anymore in the world. Only peace and happiness.

Yeah, this is why I kept saying that even when FF14 do have good story, they only know how to write ONE type of story.