2.0 player here we've been wanting a gate keeping system for years SQ E said no and alot of us left or the very few who stayed only do new content then dip.

It won't work we've tried, asked, begged, made multiple forums about it etc. The answer is NO live with it or move on. It's not your game, It's Yoshi-Ps game.

On a side note your sub fee is worthless compared to how many people who would quit because of it so either make your own game or move on an play another game/MMO.