Hamel Defense BRING IT BACK!

[Fawkes]

Besieged was cooler.

[Andevom]

Besieged was cooler.

Besieged was a mess, especially if you had a Lv. 8 Beastmen raid. And the consequences of failure were you lost the Candy, which screwed over the entire server. Getting it back required several groups to sacrifice themselves to weaken the boss enough for the last group to take them out. Thematically, that seems pretty badass and heroic. In practice, it was an uncoordinated disaster 99% of the time.

Campaign, on the other hand, was much better. The enemies didn't overwhelmingly outmatch the players, and the battles were much more frequent. You basically got all the good parts of Besieged, but in a more refined package.