Quote Originally Posted by VoidsentStatus View Post
This is what most people seem to not understand. Should is not the same as actually existing. Should I have a healer that doesn't do aoe damage? No. But if I run 100 dungeons, I will find several of them. Should a dps know their aoe rotation by ShB,EW,DT? Yes. But that doesn't mean that will happen every run. If you go to Youtube and type in "dawntrail final trial cutscenes" and find a certain upload that was around 3 weeks ago, 40k views, 36min long, you will see a player that is at the final trial in DT. That is using aoe abilities on a single target boss. That is doing 3-5 oGCD's consistently before a GCD. That is taking 10-15s off of using GCD's. That is weaving slowly to the point of consistently clipping the downtime rotation even. And all of these non-optimal mistakes are made consistently throughout the entire fight and are not just merely misclicks. Should this be happening at Level 100 content? No. But guess what? Someone had them in party for every dungeon and trial they did up to that point. A tank dealt with them at some point. At no point has a tank ever asserted that these incidents happen every run or that they happen most runs. "Should" is not an argument against YPYT because it does not cover 100% of instances, and therefore does not address every situation.
This is confusing, it sounds like you're talking about the generally understood outliers one faces in old content, as well as the Concept of "Basic Competency" that a minority in the forums takes as a form of elitism, when it's just about having players know the bare minimum when it comes to doing their part in Content with other players.

Which, YPYT is only a small fragment of the said variables that can show up. (And "SHOULDN'T" be something that shows up. Cause it's always about the Ego of a Tank.)
[And in the times it isn't the Tank, it's Clear as day where it's occurring. as Tanks, Healers, and DPS that understand what Basic Competency is, Know where thr issues are. and are also understanding and forgiving of accidents.]