Quote Originally Posted by Zackneifein View Post
The reviews from "professional" website and the content creators. Endwalker was universally praised by both of them, the complains were mainly contained in this forum.

No expansion had so much divisive review (and I'm not talking about user's one with review bombing on both side becoming a well known thing) than Dawntrail nor had the content creator giving this "meh" feeling about it.
And that's two of the best entry point for new player that an MMORPG need to stay alive. I mean, even in some of the good reviews, they say that the MSQ is mid at best, praising only the rest.

You may find it stupid or unfair but no expansion, even Stormblood, have ever been as divisive as Dawntrail and it's a problem for Square Enix.
Stormblood was ABSOLUTELY more divisive and your insistence that it wasn't just shows you weren't around for it, or are just being dishonest.