Yoshi P - Your next live letter, DT msq and the damage to the brand

[Tunda]

Whoever comes here saying it's a failure like 1.0 wasn't there to experience it or doesn't remember how bad it was. I can't take anyone who makes that claim seriously.



Who knows. I thought post HW with the Warriors of Darkness felt like bad filler and they surprised me with Shadowbringers later on.

that is the issue.. HW was a great expansion,, DT isn't

do you compare Niddhog and estenien ark vs sphene and wuk lamat ice cream ark?

[Volgia]

that is the issue.. HW was a great expansion,, DT isn't

do you compare Niddhog and estenien ark vs sphene and wuk lamat ice cream ark?

I will say that one of the reasons HW feels like a really good expansions its cuz you can contrast it coming out ARR which story and characters felt kind of generic.

Dunno, I find them to be DIFFERENT, not even comparable. I personally REALLY liked Sphene and Erenville, and I thought Wuk's story was nice and cozy the first arc around, I didn't find them to be perfect or beyond criticisms though.
If we are here to analyse the story I'm all up for it, but I am hesitant to give criticisms were it's due because it gets flooded with doomers, with Wuk Lamat haters and I don't want to invite the more extreme haters over to have a taken on it.

EDIT: I wanted to add that I find DT to be great expansion, even if I find the story isn't as strong as HW or ShB.