I was gonna make a thread on this as well, glad I'm not alone. I also really prefer the old look of the upper eyeshadow/eyelashes. There is an eye option (number 4 I think) that has a thicker eyeshadow and it doesn't change the shape too much, but still it doesn't give back the old look. Posting the comparisons I made with the current in-game versions on the right.





Hopefully something can still be done about this, either by reverting the change or by adding it as an option to the facial features category. The old eyeshadow itself works as a semi-transparent and almost textureless model that drops down from the upper eyelid, covering the upper quarters of the irises from certain angles, and thus giving middies a really interesting gaze that I have come to love.