MSQ: "One life for one world"

[Enkidoh]

It's not broken, but just has mechanics that are very difficult. The strategy for this duty works as others have mentioned, so unless you're trying to do it in gear that is too low ilevel, even if you're failing you should be able to pass it eventually, due to the Echo boost effect kicking in that should superpower your stats, and does stack if you're failing repeatedly and retrying it.

Also, are you keeping the duty set as 'Normal' difficulty after failing it? There is nothing to gain keeping it on 'normal' if you're having trouble with this duty unless you're deliberately looking for a challenge. Set it to 'Very Easy' and it should help you also a great deal.

[Frizze]

Nope. Its broken as F. 2022.

Yeah, every person before you said the same thing and was proven wrong. So... im going to stick to the assumption that you arent doing it right as you have provided no details to the contrary. And look at that! One post before yours in this very thread someone listed not only a kill order for the NPCs, but a tip to make the most important part of the fight(channeling the aether blade) easier. We all agree that this fight could have been designed better, but it is perfectly clearable as is. And who knows. Theyve been updating bits and pieces of the MSQ as they go. This patch might be looked at again via the 6.3 patch in 4ish months. It COULD be improved. But again, it doesnt need to be fixed. Cause it aint broke.

[Densoro]

I don't get why people are being so condescending about this quest.

I know there's supposed to be a Blade of Light in front of Alisaie. I know that it has no physical body, and I have to click the name directly. I know that I need to defeat anybody who's aggro'd on me or her, or we won't be able to focus on channeling. And yet, even when I do that, there are times when the Blade of Light just...isn't there. How do I make it reappear so that I can continue interacting with it? It's so frustrating having the NPCs bark orders for me to do something I can't do because the item has not respawned yet. "GET UP ON THE HYDRA'S BACK, GET UP ON THE HYDRA'S BACK,' except the entire hydra has temporarily despawned.

Like, do people realize it's possible to pay attention and adore this game and still have valid criticisms of encounter design? I'm not used to seeing the community behave so dismissively and throw some imagined 'fault' onto new players like they're doing in this thread.

[Mesarthim]

I don't get why people are being so condescending about this quest.

I know there's supposed to be a Blade of Light in front of Alisaie. I know that it has no physical body, and I have to click the name directly. I know that I need to defeat anybody who's aggro'd on me or her, or we won't be able to focus on channeling. And yet, even when I do that, there are times when the Blade of Light just...isn't there. How do I make it reappear so that I can continue interacting with it? It's so frustrating having the NPCs bark orders for me to do something I can't do because the item has not respawned yet. "GET UP ON THE HYDRA'S BACK, GET UP ON THE HYDRA'S BACK,' except the entire hydra has temporarily despawned.

Like, do people realize it's possible to pay attention and adore this game and still have valid criticisms of encounter design? I'm not used to seeing the community behave so dismissively and throw some imagined 'fault' onto new players like they're doing in this thread.

I know I am a necromancer for clearing palace solo, but you're a necromancer in your own right with posts being from 2+ years ago. I don't remember ever failing this quest nor am I going to go back and read a thread from over TWO YEARS AGO to understand why people are stuck.

If you're failing, try again or lower the difficulty.

[Enkidoh]

I don't get why people are being so condescending about this quest.

I know there's supposed to be a Blade of Light in front of Alisaie. I know that it has no physical body, and I have to click the name directly. I know that I need to defeat anybody who's aggro'd on me or her, or we won't be able to focus on channeling. And yet, even when I do that, there are times when the Blade of Light just...isn't there. How do I make it reappear so that I can continue interacting with it? It's so frustrating having the NPCs bark orders for me to do something I can't do because the item has not respawned yet. "GET UP ON THE HYDRA'S BACK, GET UP ON THE HYDRA'S BACK,' except the entire hydra has temporarily despawned.

Like, do people realize it's possible to pay attention and adore this game and still have valid criticisms of encounter design? I'm not used to seeing the community behave so dismissively and throw some imagined 'fault' onto new players like they're doing in this thread.

As I recall the Blade of Light indeed isn't always on the screen, but only becomes available when it's actually scripted into the battle as needed, based on how the battle progresses and how you fill up the gauge (you can tell when it's now available when Alisaie says something like "lend me your aether" or something along those lines. That's when you have to stop what you're doing and focus on the Blade of Light - of course with Darklander and his flunkies snapping at your heels, this can be easier said than done.

And yes, it's a very difficult battle, but it's not impossible - I failed three or four times myself until I finally realized what I was doing wrong (didn't actually notice the Blade of Light when it became available, and then couldn't click on it in time). Once I managed to get a handle on that mechanic, I eventually passed it.

So don't despair, the fight is hard, but use the advice that is given, and the knowledge that the Blade isn't always on the screen but will become available at scripted points in the fight and that is when you have to click on it to feed it your aether to boost the gauge, then you'll soon emerge victorious (battered and bruised though).