Honestly just sounds like you're all bored of the game and looking for an external solution. None of what you're saying is valid in my experience. I get that you want it to be different than it is, but the criticism doesn't hold up the way you think it does. When your ideas are challenged too, you just do some weird deflection and throw out buzz words.

That one guy talking about old content being trivial when overgeared, I mean?? yes? That's how mmos work? Of all the mmos on the market right now, ffxiv is the only one that actually allows you to even re-experience old content at all without going far out of your way to do so. The fact that we can even fight nidhogg at level 90 and it be a fight is huge. Content in ongoing mmos will always have an expiration date. That's why they make ultimate raids.

To be frank it's just exhausting to even listen to anything you have to say. I feel bad for square enix if they even consider threads like this at all. Most if not all of your posts just scream jaded and burnt out.