Scholars used to be awesome; I hope 7.0 goes back to the basics.

[TheDustyOne]

I think you're taking "no one would complain" too literally here. Again, hyperbole, not everything is literal. Everyone will always have some pain points and things they want improved, I even listed my own problems with SB SCH on my comment, but that still doesn't stop the fact that what was said in that thread was still highly enthusiastic about Scholars old playstyle, about how they'd happily play it again, and would prefer to be stuck with that for 4+ years compared to ShB/EW kit. The bittersweet comments are mostly around the fact that we would've spent 4 years going in a circle, that SCH effectively wouldn't have progressed beyond lvl 70 in a game soon reaching lvl 100. They want more because FFXIV should've offered more after 4+ years. SB SCH would be better than now sure, but we should've evolved off of that into something greater and instead became a broilspammer with a fairy.