Rhalgrs Reach should never have existed

[Nezerius]

My brother, Ive consistently go there frequently every week. It still looks boring and the music is annoying!

There's a difference between finding the place to be boring, and calling it a ruined town. One's a perfectly fine opinion, the other is an incorrect statement.

2. If I wanted that aesthetic, Old Sharlayan is much more appealing

Except Old Sharlayan couldn't be visited when Idyllshire was the endgame hub.