On Themis [6.4 SPOILER]

[Cleretic]

To the OP that's how I see it with Themis.

Okay I might be dumb or just really confused, but when all the lamenting is going on its just their memories stuffed inside a soul (that might not even be theirs) post death correct? So how did Athena get ahold of any of that? Themis for example shouldn't know some things he does as unless she's able to do something akin to what Hydelean did with Emet-Selch's soul and yoink stuff from the 1st he shouldn't know about our 5.3 fight or any post sundering stuff. Heck would his memories even be floating around the 1st's sea? Even though we know memories and the soul are two separate ather components they're also attached to the soul, right? And we were told that Themis at least was used up when he sent us to Elpis. Eric's soul got reborn into Claudien.

To clarify: The memories seemed to come from the memory crystal that started all this. Erich and Lahabrea were etched onto random souls, but with Themis she somehow pinned down the actual one, probably because he died very recently, which is why he remembered the events of the not-as-distant past when Lahabrea didn't. Which... yeah, actually doesn't make a lot of sense, since he'd be off in the First's aetherial sea. Hydaelyn was still alive at the time, maybe she moved him like she did Minfilia and Emet and just didn't say anything. Or maybe Athena did it (she mentioned he was proving more difficult, after all), although I'm not sure why she'd have gone through the effort.

[Tehmon]

To clarify: The memories seemed to come from the memory crystal that started all this. Erich and Lahabrea were etched onto random souls, but with Themis she somehow pinned down the actual one, probably because he died very recently, which is why he remembered the events of the not-as-distant past when Lahabrea didn't. Which... yeah, actually doesn't make a lot of sense, since he'd be off in the First's aetherial sea. Hydaelyn was still alive at the time, maybe she moved him like she did Minfilia and Emet and just didn't say anything. Or maybe Athena did it (she mentioned he was proving more difficult, after all), although I'm not sure why she'd have gone through the effort.

I think it'd be mighty horrendous of Hydaelyn to not have moved his soul as well, so I think it's that.