1000+ ATT Power Club :D

[Kaeko]

You can't seriously be advocating building a DD set built around having +40STR off a potion that lasts 40 seconds?

Beyond this, not going to get into a "best DD set" argument here just because I think people can make their own choices given the simplicity of the system.

[Rydin]

That's nice. There can be a number of way to achieve it. Point is it's better to get STR and INT to cap before focusing on Attack Power, when given the choice.

Its all about the numbers.. getting STR to cap may be more important... but if you were choosing between 10 STR and 100 ATK then the choice is ATK all the way
I know thats an extreme but where is the cutoff?

You can't seriously be advocating building a DD set built around having +40STR off a potion that lasts 40 seconds?

Beyond this, not going to get into a "best DD set" argument here just because I think people can make their own choices given the simplicity of the system.

Im interested to do the math:
on one hand you do a set amount of damage the entire time
or
You do slightly less damage... but 15% of the time you do quite a bit more damage
A case can be made for either depending on what "Slightly less damage" amounts to

I wasn't going into best DD set... just posing a hypothetical and showing that "STR is better than ATK" is a blanket statement that doesn't always hold true and advocating players to do some tests on their own to see what they come up with

[NoctisUmbra]

I wasn't going into best DD set... just posing a hypothetical and showing that "STR is better than ATK" is a blanket statement that doesn't always hold true and advocating players to do some tests on their own to see what they come up with

1 point of STR is better than 1 point of attack until STR caps at 350, is a fact and not a blanket statement.

Your example of 100 ATK vs 10 STR is hyperbole and not a decision one would come across regularly, if at all. However, if faced with such a choice I'm sure it is quite obvious that 100 ATK is the way to go.

[Rydin]

1 point of STR is better than 1 point of attack until STR caps at 350, is a fact and not a blanket statement.

This is a good start.... But people don't say that... people say Cap STR first... which implies that any amount of STR is better than any amount of ATK until you get to 350 STR... which is just not true
Now let's be more specific...
After STR cap... STR to ATK equal 2:3
So after the cap... I'd opt for 30 STR over 19 ATK, but not over 21 ATK
These are the things that are important

Pre-cap... Seiken, Kaeko or Noctis... did you see any type of increase that would give us a ratio?
Also... It's rare that you would hit 350 on the dot... so if you're piece goes over 350.. then you'd have to create a baseline value and treat STR>350 as a completely different stat than STR<351
So say (This isn't true but for the sake of argument that)
STR1:ATK is 2:3
STR2:Atk is 3:2
That would mean every 2 STR above the cap would equal 3 ATK, and 3 ATK would equal 4.5 STR below the cap
So you could say each point of STR at 350 or below = 9, each STR point above 350 = 4 and each ATK point = 6
and then you'd be able to score each piece accordingly
All just an example... but you get my point

[Meatdawg]

You can't seriously be advocating building a DD set built around having +40STR off a potion that lasts 40 seconds?

Beyond this, not going to get into a "best DD set" argument here just because I think people can make their own choices given the simplicity of the system.

Exactly. I would try to push stats with gear first always and never relay on food/potions to hit a target value.

Having 50 str gloves for example also lets you swap in some very valuable acc rings. (don't underestimate acc)

This is all about WS damage, which is much > then AA damage.

There are still occasion when factoring in lower DLEVEL that atk is just > str as well i believe.

[Rydin]

Exactly. I would try to push stats with gear first always and never relay on food/potions to hit a target value.

Having 50 str gloves for example also lets you swap in some very valuable acc rings. (don't underestimate acc)

This is all about WS damage, which is much > then AA damage.

There are still occasion when factoring in lower DLEVEL that atk is just > str as well i believe.

true... some good ACC does go a long way

I do want to parse 4 minutes on a MOB with STR at 350

and then 4 minutes with STR at 310 and a potion for 30-40 seconds of it

That 30-40 seconds would be the most possible damage a MNK can do.... would be interesting

And you're right... I wouldn't factor in potions... but why not factor in food?
It is very possible to keep it up indefinitely