Encounters need to be designed to let people play the class they want to.

[DoctorMog]

ok... then ask yourself this?
If 2 people were shouting 7/8 cutter's cry, Chimera...

One was WAR, WHM, WHM, BRD, BLM BLM BLM

and

the other was PLD, WHM, WHM MNK, MNK, DRG, DRG

which one would you choose to run with?
And so I'll ask again... is it really the communities fault?

Simple,

People who suck at FFXIV pick the BLM stacked group for easymode.

People who don't suck pick the other group.

[Rydin]

Simple,

People who suck at FFXIV pick the BLM stacked group for easymode.

People who don't suck pick the other group.

I think the non-stacked one would be more fun... for sure... but I don't think someone sucks because they go for the easier win... many people don't like to take risks
If it takes a highly skilled party to speed run Aurum Vale with every class present but a mediocre party can do it when stacked a certain way... you already know what everyone will do...
I think both SE AND the community can share blame for that

But I do feel like content at 2.0 will be much more varied and diverse....
So I try not to be too hypercritical of things right now