Let's talk about Alliance roulette and ilvl cheese for a sec.

[Deveryn]

nono, I got CT with someone who was stark naked, there was no newcomer. No one was in cutscene, there was no such prompt on the chat saying "Someone's new to the instance!". But someone was naked and then their HP bar miraculously grew.

I think you'd be hard pressed to find enough examples of that to make a case for the alleged prevalence of this activity and its effect on roulettes. You can't even tell if everyone else present has all alliances unlocked. Something else that's been overlooked is that people will likely queue CT directly if it comes up on Wondrous Tails.

And that's the issue. Assuming this is indeed all paranoia, there isn't much to quell it. Which is why you see these threads constantly happening. I'm willing to admit it's probably not real, but I also don't have any convincing evidence to show me otherwise. Thus I assume it's real. Not "guilty until proven otherwise", but more the idea of "Okay, well... I'm willing to accept it might not be much, but are you sure it's not an exploit?"
And being told to shut up and accept it isn't answering that question. Hence, again, why these threads keep popping up.

Alliance roulette only offers two things of value, tomes and xp. Trying to raise hell over an easily avoidable situation with a variety of alternatives is going to come with responses like that.

I'll continue to push for a better solution that actually works for all parties. This idea of dumping it in MSQ roulette is inconsiderate of those that want to use that. It's also ridiculous to expect CT to ever fill on that.

And you know why threads like this continue to crop up?

Because it continues to be an issue.

More like y'all don't bother to check if there's an active thread. You have to come in and start a conversation and be the center of attention and demand something change instead of finding the one thread to support whatever idea.