Unpopular opinion on island sanctuarys.

[LalafellDown]

Not sure why people advocate for instanced housing. Island sanctuary is way better. The automation and tending to the farm is fun. With housing you just fill your place with junk and get nothing out of it. I haven’t seen one person in their houses when I visit, because housing brings nothing.

I hope the developers continue to expand island sanctuary. The gathering should be evolved to active style gathering. Like swinging a sword and hitting a hit box as the tree shakes ands falls over. There should be less buildings and instead have them be upgraded to look different and produce more.

There should be exploration and building all over the island. Being able to build in secret areas of the island for unique buffs and activities or shortcuts. As we wait for the automation of the island we need more activities. More biomes like desert and urban should be added to the island. Allow us to build up a small city for people to come and live in. Allow friends to contribute resources to friends island and trade resources with one another or better yet allow friends to own an island together.

Island sanctuary is wonderful because it’s solo content that doesn’t depend on a party. Unlike all the savage and extreme content that die over time.

The devs got something good but need to evolve it from point and click to more active combat style.

[WhiteWitch]

Island sanctuary is wonderful because it’s solo content that doesn’t depend on a party. Unlike all the savage and extreme content that die over time.

The devs got something good but need to evolve it from point and click to more active combat style.

solo content that as of right now does not benefit the game other than some glamors. it does not interact with farming for thavnarian onions or anything people need in any way. it needs some improvements IMO. there are way better options to get materias.

[Opinionated]

Not sure why people advocate for instanced housing.

Because currently housing is limited, meaning I can pay the same amount of real money for the game, its expansions and the monthly sub as you but if you have a large house, the chances of me realistically getting the same experience as you are little to none. I can even buy the same limited housing items they sell on the mogstore, again, for real money, yet I might never be actually able to get a house in game.

Island sanctuary is way better.

Island sanctuary isnt housing. It doesnt offer the same content as housing.

With housing you just fill your place with junk and get nothing out of it.

Fun is subjective. What you might find fun, others might not, vice versa. But if that's too difficult of a concept, gardening is an example of an actual mechanic that can not be done anywhere else but with a house.

haven’t seen one person in their houses when I visit, because housing brings nothing.

I love dungeons but don't spend every single second of my playtime inside one.