The feeling of beeing Home ...

[XiRon]

Thancred did WHAT?

sucked AT FIGHTING RANJIT lmao I thought I typed that but my eyes were faster than my fingers.

[aveyond-dreams]

Can't say I'm particularly excited to follow Garlemald's story as it transitions into yet another republic. I'm tired of the story repeating this handling of the political situation over and over again. Why was an Archades-style ending too much for this game?

[XiRon]

The Akasadora? Or are you talking about the third tribe assuming we not averting from the formula and still get three that would be crafting if we were to follow how ShB did it? And are you ot are you not wanting more Garlemald? Cause just dropping by and getting an "Oh yeah everything is good here sorry for not getting on the linkshell or sending moogle mail to Tataru or whatever to say everything is good and Julius is now mayor. We'll be returning to Sharlyean..." feels like a bit of a wasted trip.

we already know all the beast tribes unless they pull an arr and add more than 3.
Arkasadora, Lopprits and Omicrons.
No Garlemald Restoration we SHOULD restore Bozja and Dalmasca but god forbid races that arent Hyur or Hyur But French ever matter in any capacity

[Theodric]

You disagreed so you must be wanting to be gatekeeping.

Disagreement isn't the issue, it's the weird personal attacks, ridicule and insinuations that people take issue with.

Jeeqbit is disagreeing with the OP but isn't attacking people or ridiculing them for their opinions. So it's definitely possible to accomplish.

[Jeeqbit]

The Akasadora? Or are you talking about the third tribe assuming we not averting from the formula and still get three that would be crafting if we were to follow how ShB did it?

The last one, which I assume is the loporrits. They could land in Garlemald because beast tribes are known to move from the usual habitat.

And are you ot are you not wanting more Garlemald? Cause just dropping by and getting an "Oh yeah everything is good here sorry for not getting on the linkshell or sending moogle mail to Tataru or whatever to say everything is good and Julius is now mayor. We'll be returning to Sharlyean..." feels like a bit of a wasted trip.

Time away in the MSQ is often used to imply a sidequest. In the MSQ we get references to Krile being away for Eureka, Cid and others being away for the raids, or the investigation of the empty.

[Silverbane]

I feel like this whole "New Adventure" thing is what Yoshida wanted, not me.

Oh, get over yourself:

Everything in this game is what Yoshida and his team wanted, not you.

That's how it works:

• They, the creators, decide what goes into their creation.
• You, the consumer, decide whether to buy it.

Don't like it? Then start your very own game design studio.
See if "what you want" makes for a game as successful as FFXIV.

[SannaR]

Disagreement isn't the issue, it's the weird personal attacks, ridicule and insinuations that people take issue with.

Jeeqbit is disagreeing with the OP but isn't attacking people or ridiculing them for their opinions. So it's definitely possible to accomplish.

Yet there are those in this thread even who have acted as someone disagreeing with them even without name calling is akin to gatekeeping. When it comes to disliking a part of the game. Don't act like there aren't those who agree with the OP who don't employ personal attacks ect in their opening salvo.

[Theodric]

Oh, get over yourself:

Everything in this game is what Yoshida and his team wanted, not you.

That's how it works:

• They, the creators, decide what goes into their creation.
• You, the consumer, decide whether to buy it.

Don't like it? Then start your very own game design studio.
See if "what you want" makes for a game as successful as FFXIV.

Aside from all those times the development team have actively changed and compromised their vision in response to feedback from players.

I don't think Liam is the one who needs to 'get over himself'.

[Lauront]

Oh, get over yourself:

Everything in this game is what Yoshida and his team wanted, not you.

That's how it works:

• They, the creators, decide what goes into their creation.
• You, the consumer, decide whether to buy it.

Don't like it? Then start your very own game design studio.
See if "what you want" makes for a game as successful as FFXIV.

Part of what Yoshida believes/believed is the approach to making it successful is to listen to one's customers. Not exactly unheard of as a principle in business.

[AwesomeJr44]

Everything in this game is what Yoshida and his team wanted, not you.

Ah yes, the old "the creators have a right to trash their product so just leave if you don't like it" argument. I cannot wait for the day when people start taking that advice and the people who use this argument start wondering where everyone went.

Sometimes I wonder if you people even want the game to be the best it can be, or if you just want it to continue the downward spiral because you prefer eating sludge.