Hildibrand for relic? Really?

[EaraGrace]

Back to the same conversation on a completely unrelated thread.

[Rolder50]

I guess the scions sacrificing themselves to pave the way for us with no guarantee on their part to come back is just a nothing burger

It's a nothing burger because Hydaelyn literally hands you the McGuffin needed to bring them back immediately before that point, removing any possible tension.

[Knot_D]

We must have played two completely different versions of Endwalker then.

Yeah, it really prove it on your wattpad fanfics

[TsuchinokoPanda]

Clearly with your vague passive aggressive response

Don't take it personally, there seems to be a very vocal group on here that take any opportunity to hate on Endwalker because while it's fine to be disappointed with a product, they're seemingly endlessly irritated others enjoyed/interpreted it differently.

[aveyond-dreams]

Don't take it personally, there seems to be a very vocal group on here that take any opportunity to hate on Endwalker because while it's fine to be disappointed with a product, they're seemingly endlessly irritated others enjoyed/interpreted it differently.

If we use this logic then I imagine you'd tell your fellow Hrothgar players to remain silent on the ongoing hairstyle crisis? Please.

[TsuchinokoPanda]

If we use this logic then I imagine you'd tell your fellow Hrothgar players to remain silent on the ongoing hairstyle crisis? Please.

I've been pretty vocal on my ear removage, it's the reason I even joined this forum. You're just being upset for upset's sake. We get it, you hate Endwalker, there's a whole thread for it already. Please stop being so antagonistic towards people.

[Hurlstone]

Honestly? I love this idea. I cannot wait to see just how the story unfolds and how Hildy, Greg and the others are involved in this epic quest. It will be a nice change of pace from how relics where forged in the past, I hope. As for it being locked behind a quest-chain, thats fair, but I like how they are giving players a reason to do the older content. It does not feel too different to me from how the Shadowbringer ones where behind the SB raids.

[Xeronia]

Don't take it personally, there seems to be a very vocal group on here that take any opportunity to hate on Endwalker because while it's fine to be disappointed with a product, they're seemingly endlessly irritated others enjoyed/interpreted it differently.

I mean no offense but I simply came here to leave my feedback I am not pleased with the direction of EW and it's content thus far. I understand why some people may be fervently making arguments about that given even I have to question "You can just netfilx something on the side" as a recommended way to do the content when I personally would rather unsub then be told "just don't interact with the content then". Why would I pay a sub if I am not interacting with the content, by that logic I can just youtube everything and save 15 bucks a month. As stated previously the relic is something I always look forward to and seeing it is stuck behind a quest chain I immensely disliked really makes me consider the direction of EW and how much it no longer seems like the game I fell in love with in HW/SB. I absolutely understand people having such strong opinions and feedback if they are starting to see a direction they disagree with which arguably goes against what they believed the game was prior, the point of forums is to bring these concerns forward.

Overall I would say EW is a massive disappointment on several fronts and this just adds to a pile for a lot of people.

[TsuchinokoPanda]

I mean no offense but I simply came here to leave my feedback I am not pleased with the direction of EW and it's content thus far. I understand why some people may be fervently making arguments about that given even I have to question "You can just netfilx something on the side" as a recommended way to do the content when I personally would rather unsub then be told "just don't interact with the content then". Why would I pay a sub if I am not interacting with the content, by that logic I can just youtube everything and save 15 bucks a month. As stated previously the relic is something I always look forward to and seeing it is stuck behind a quest chain I immensely disliked really makes me consider the direction of EW and how much it no longer seems like the game I fell in love with in HW/SB. I absolutely understand people having such strong opinions and feedback if they are starting to see a direction they disagree with which arguably goes against what they believed the game was prior, the point of forums is to bring these concerns forward.

Overall I would say EW is a massive disappointment on several fronts and this just adds to a pile for a lot of people.

Ok, and that's fine. I'm not trying to pick a fight with you and you're perfectly fine with being disappointed. I was more taking umbrage with those who get needlessly hostile with people in discussions like these. You're being polite, concise and getting the reason why you're disagreeing known without punching down other's opinions. I sincerely wish you find something rekindle your love with FFXIV sooner than later.

[ballprince]

I mean no offense but I simply came here to leave my feedback I am not pleased with the direction of EW and it's content thus far. I understand why some people may be fervently making arguments about that given even I have to question "You can just netfilx something on the side" as a recommended way to do the content when I personally would rather unsub then be told "just don't interact with the content then". Why would I pay a sub if I am not interacting with the content, by that logic I can just youtube everything and save 15 bucks a month. As stated previously the relic is something I always look forward to and seeing it is stuck behind a quest chain I immensely disliked really makes me consider the direction of EW and how much it no longer seems like the game I fell in love with in HW/SB. I absolutely understand people having such strong opinions and feedback if they are starting to see a direction they disagree with which arguably goes against what they believed the game was prior, the point of forums is to bring these concerns forward.

Overall I would say EW is a massive disappointment on several fronts and this just adds to a pile for a lot of people.

You're one of the few people on the forums I have seen put it really well, and though I am on the opposite side of the fence I can see more clearly now the frustration.

I think people are too ready to kiss the ground SE walks on in regards to story content sometimes and forget that this criticism is to be expected and should be heard out just the same as the people who loved it.