Mentor Roulette's Achievement Grind Harms New Players' Experiences

[Jeeqbit]

We should have a roulette specifically for Extreme trials if they are going to be in a roulette. People would do it because there are people who actually enjoy high-end content and just find it fun.

[RobynDaBank]

We should have a roulette specifically for Extreme trials if they are going to be in a roulette. People would do it because there are people who actually enjoy high-end content and just find it fun.

Nah, people will always do it with PF. Some curious souls and some newbies will queue up from there, have a trashfire occur, and learn their lesson.

[Jaquan]

Nah, people will always do it with PF. Some curious souls and some newbies will queue up from there, have a trashfire occur, and learn their lesson.

From my experience as a newbie and a person enjoying taking it slow through older content and experiencing as it was intended... Party Finder isn't exactly best choice overall. I've noticed people generally assume you just want a clear and suggest doing it unsynced. Sometimes I even wonder if there's a point for that content to exist...

[MellowMink]

I have a potentially radical opinion that extreme trials should only be done in Party Finder, never Duty Finder. Party Finder is really easy to use and has so many options available.

[MellowMink]

Oh, and please remove the Main Scenario Roulette dungeons and trial from the Mentor Roulette still; even with the instance updates, it’s still something that almost all mentors would only want to ever do when they can also get the Main Scenario Roulette bonuses. You’re more likely to just have people leave immediately as a mentor even with the brief time penalty, and I don’t blame them. Those dungeons and trial are straightforward too.

[SturmChurro]

I have a potentially radical opinion that extreme trials should only be done in Party Finder, never Duty Finder. Party Finder is really easy to use and has so many options available.

Oh, and please remove the Main Scenario Roulette dungeons and trial from the Mentor Roulette still; even with the instance updates, it’s still something that almost all mentors would only want to ever do when they can also get the Main Scenario Roulette bonuses. You’re more likely to just have people leave immediately as a mentor even with the brief time penalty, and I don’t blame them. Those dungeons and trial are straightforward too.

Good opinions actually. The only thing I would add is also removing the mount reward from it specifically.

[Jeeqbit]

Nah, people will always do it with PF. Some curious souls and some newbies will queue up from there, have a trashfire occur, and learn their lesson.

No, they will not. Hardly anyone does synced extremes in party finder. Only a tiny fraction of people. Everyone else does them unsynced. A roulette is different because it forces them to be synced.