Final Fantasy XIV Hot Takes

[kpxmanifesto]

The forums suck and are overwhelmingly negative, no matter what. And it blows everything out of proportion. Everyone outside of the official forums on other platforms usually think the exact opposite of whatever is posted here.

The official forums is one of the few places where people can freely discuss the shortcomings of the game. Other platforms, like the FFXIV reddit page, will take measures to censor criticism. For example, if this thread were created on the FFXIV reddit page, it would be deleted pretty quickly.

[Teno]

The official forums is one of the few places where people can freely discuss the shortcomings of the game. Other platforms, like the FFXIV reddit page, will take measures to censor criticism. For example, if this thread were created on the FFXIV reddit page, it would be deleted pretty quickly.

Definitely, and while there is negativity people tend to take time to write detailed comments, something you'd rarely find on other forums for a game of similar scale. The FFXIV reddit is actually one of the few subreddits I dislike, between the bad memes, endless fan arts and very sparce discussions about the game itself.

[Lium]

The official forums is one of the few places where people can freely discuss the shortcomings of the game. Other platforms, like the FFXIV reddit page, will take measures to censor criticism. For example, if this thread were created on the FFXIV reddit page, it would be deleted pretty quickly.

If only it was well-rounded criticism here. It isn't. It's rounded towards negativity and that's it. But almost every video game forum is like that.

And yes, this thread would likely be deleted on the FFXIV sub because it doesn't add anything constructive. It's nearly 30 pages of crapping on the game. I've seen some great discussions on Reddit, Discord, social media and various websites and blogs about the game. Opinion are varied across them all. It's not all positive and it's not all negative. Especially Reddit where there are a number of subs dedicated to video games, RPGs and a main one dedicated to MMOs. The MMO subreddit is worse than the forums in that they crap all over every MMO, no matter which one it is. So, if you think they don't go after FFXIV then you clearly have never been there.

But even in that sub the opinions are more well-rounded than the forums, which is usually just tearing the game down. Mostly over stuff that players straight up don't understand. I am still convinced that the majority of people that post on the forums did not understand the story of EW at all and I will die on that hill. The few that have legitimate criticisms I tip my hat to because their posts are more constructive.

Then there are just trolls but they've always been around and always will be.

Edit: Like this person here. I honestly have respect for them (no joke) for just plainly coming out and saying they skipped all the story stuff. They are probably just joking but this to me is the 99% of the forums.

I skipped the entire story of FFXIV. I have not watched a single cutscene. I don’t know what I’m fighting for, all I know is I look good doing it while the NPC’s sit back and make me do everything.

I have no idea what a Y’shtola is or why everyone’s obsessed with it (I assume it’s like baby Yoda).

And I can’t stand the fact that 2b boots gives my character clown feet.

[kpxmanifesto]

If only it was well-rounded criticism here. It isn't. It's rounded towards negativity and that's it.

This is such a one-sided view of everything that happens on these forums. Honestly, this is just the whole "your criticism isn't constructive" debate again. It's the same argument that people use to defend the game: by gatekeeping the term "constructive criticism."

Edit: Like this person here. I honestly have respect for them (no joke) for just plainly coming out and saying they skipped all the story stuff. They are probably just joking but this to me is the 99% of the forums.

You cherrypicked one person's post where they said they skipped the entire story and now you say: "but this to me is the 99% of the forums." How is anyone here going to take you seriously now after seeing you make such a sweeping generalization?