Dear warriors, sincerely healers

[Rein_eon_Osborne]

Unpopular but obviously true opinion: WARs need to be nerfed.

What about them to nerf? Sustainability?
If so, then there’s no reason to bring them outside aesthetic & simplicity reasons.

That’s pretty much the only edge they have over other tanks. (Except the posterboi PLD, RIP PLD)

I do have to say that Raw Intuition/Bloodwhetting/Nascent Flash’s description is slightly misleading. I was imagining it would only heal them for flat 400p for each weaponskills performed. Turns out that value multiplies in AoE situation. Definitely not what I expected.

[ForteNightshade]

What about them to nerf? Sustainability?
If so, then there’s no reason to bring them outside aesthetic & simplicity reasons.

That’s pretty much the only edge they have over other tanks. (Except the posterboi PLD, RIP PLD)

I do have to say that Raw Intuition/Bloodwhetting/Nascent Flash’s description is slightly misleading. I was imagining it would only heal them for flat 400p for each weaponskills performed. Turns out that value multiplies in AoE situation. Definitely not what I expected.

The only reasonable nerf they could do that wouldn't otherwise kill Warrior is to give Bloodwhetting a fall off. That way it's only impacted in dungeons. Even with a 50% fall off from the second hit onward, the critical hit heals from Chaotic Cyclone would still be strong. Although, I think 25% is more fair.

If they straight up nerf Bloodwhetting wholesale, then they need to up Warrior's damage. We saw in Shadowbringers that decent but otherwise incidental healing just doesn't matter in a raid setting. Warrior was decidedly the least played tank, and among the least played jobs in the meta setting. It often less than 5%; getting even as low as not being taken at all.