How is it circular? I didn't agree with you throwing out the dish. I simply gave an example for you to know when not to make certain dishes and when to let someone else make the dish for you. In this case I compared to the preview video to the patch. The preview video always translates poorly to the patch. The good smell of food does not always translate to poor tasting food. You're example was pretty poor to begin with, but it looks like I made it work in my favor.
Also I can say from your example don't throw away the dish whether it smells good or bad, just don't complain until you actually try it!
/thread