Ast - Defensive cooldown endwalker "Speculation

[WaxSw]

if the target has card effect currently on them its removed and is healed for additional 200-300 potency over 30 seconds

With this you pretty much guarantee that 99% of the time you woudnt give it to someone with cards, for the regen effect if the total heal is 200-300 potency it would be so weak you'd rather not use it on people with cards at all, if it were per tick we're talking about 2000 to 3000 total potency which would be even stronger than ED at 1HP and still outside life/death scenarios people woudnt use it, there is also the problem that is a single target heal that seems to get the bonus of cards but cards go to dps and the single target heals usually go to the tanks. Also the status immune woudnt happen in the game because thats how devs a lot of time check that mechanics have been done properly.

Fate's Choice

This is just something that I woudnt like to see, you have 2/3 chances to get a rdps increase and 1/3 chances of getting a defensive cd, this is bad because to begin with would add more layers of rng simply for the sake of adding them making Ast gameplay more frustrating imo, now your personal dps also changes randomly because a skill says so, not because you've done something well/wrong. The defensive cooldown on rng may as well not be there, when you use cooldowns you want consistency not just power, everyone would take a plain 20% damage mitigation over something that gives 50% damage mitigation with a 50% chance of not mitigating because what you want is to have the buff for X attack/mechanic not having something that may or may not cause your death.

Also since it has dps increases tied to it you can bet it would be used as offensive cooldown instead of a heal cooldown the majority of the time

[Sedalia]

With this you pretty much guarantee that 99% of the time you woudnt give it to someone with cards, for the regen effect if the total heal is 200-300 potency it would be so weak you'd rather not use it on people with cards at all, if it were per tick we're talking about 2000 to 3000 total potency which would be even stronger than ED at 1HP and still outside life/death scenarios people woudnt use it, there is also the problem that is a single target heal that seems to get the bonus of cards but cards go to dps and the single target heals usually go to the tanks. Also the status immune woudnt happen in the game because thats how devs a lot of time check that mechanics have been done properly.



This is just something that I woudnt like to see, you have 2/3 chances to get a rdps increase and 1/3 chances of getting a defensive cd, this is bad because to begin with would add more layers of rng simply for the sake of adding them making Ast gameplay more frustrating imo, now your personal dps also changes randomly because a skill says so, not because you've done something well/wrong. The defensive cooldown on rng may as well not be there, when you use cooldowns you want consistency not just power, everyone would take a plain 20% damage mitigation over something that gives 50% damage mitigation with a 50% chance of not mitigating because what you want is to have the buff for X attack/mechanic not having something that may or may not cause your death.

Also since it has dps increases tied to it you can bet it would be used as offensive cooldown instead of a heal cooldown the majority of the time

kinda like assize?