Quote Originally Posted by Goji1639 View Post
Someone who pulls during a cutscene can say it was an accident, but so can someone who doesn't follow the tank into the boss room. I know a lot of times when I see a cutscene rolling, especially if I know it's a long one, I'll tune out for a little bit; maybe pop up my browser or turn my attention to my television. More often than not everyone lets new players watch cutscenes, so I'm not wrong to assume an active cutscene means downtime.
Actually they are not both accidents. Standing outside the boss room for a prolonged period of time isn't an accident, it is something you are actively doing (or in this case not doing). Which can be vote kicked for being AFK. If I'm a tank, I'm not usually focused on the party list, so I can easily miss someone being listed as "viewing cutscene". And in an alliance raid, I have no real way of seeing if someone in the other two parties is in a cutscene.

Quote Originally Posted by Goji1639 View Post
End of the day intentionally pulling during a cutscene is clear intent to disrupt the party. Waiting for a new player isn't clear intent to disrupt the party.
Except its not. Its a way to advance the party through the fight. It disrupts no one. I don't think there is anything wrong if the party wants to wait, but ultimately pulling the boss is up to the tank (or tanks) discretion.