What I would like to see in future monk!

[Mikey_R]

I do like the new Riddle of Fire tho, maybe add an attack at the end that ends RoF when used ? A bit like the lv80 Paladin spell ! Maybe make Tornado Kick consume the RoF buff and not Greased Lightning if used during RoF ? That would be really cool imo, and would reduce the numbers of useless skills without deleting them entirely.

The difference here is that under requiescat, you have a set amount of GCDs limited by your MP. RoF has no such restrictions and so depending on your GCD you could either end it too early or not be able to get Tornado Kick off. A better solution would be to have it be more like Life of the Dragon and Nastrond/Stardiver, so you can only use it under RoF, but it doesn't end it. Obviously, either way it is just copying another job and not adding anyting unique, which might or might not be an issue for some people.

[Eliadil]

The difference here is that under requiescat, you have a set amount of GCDs limited by your MP. RoF has no such restrictions and so depending on your GCD you could either end it too early or not be able to get Tornado Kick off. A better solution would be to have it be more like Life of the Dragon and Nastrond/Stardiver, so you can only use it under RoF, but it doesn't end it. Obviously, either way it is just copying another job and not adding anyting unique, which might or might not be an issue for some people.

I was thinking more of something in the lines of SMN's Dreadwyrm Trance, along with DeathFlare who ends the Trance when used. But your solution can work too, but needs to have a set cd on Tornado Kick, so peoples don't spam it too much. Or maybe so the goal is to have two TK in a RoF window, like Nastrond in LotD. But I admit that I prefer the first option, that isn't at least a copypasted version of another melee's kit.

[Shurrikhan]

I was thinking more of something in the lines of SMN's Dreadwyrm Trance, along with DeathFlare who ends the Trance when used. But your solution can work too, but needs to have a set cd on Tornado Kick, so peoples don't spam it too much. Or maybe so the goal is to have two TK in a RoF window, like Nastrond in LotD. But I admit that I prefer the first option, that isn't at least a copypasted version of another melee's kit.

Honestly, that combination has always felt to me like an odd mixture of button bloat and latency-punishment ever since fast-Trance / Early Deathflare fell out of use. I hit this one button so I can later hit this other button that cannot be used except under button A and I want to keep for the last moment but often fails to go off if not used more than a second earlier than my duration would appear to fade.

I'd far prefer the flexibility of Nostrond's design, especially since it doesn't waste a separate button just to activate its own in-window-only action, but would still rather see something more unique for a change, rather than more job-to-job copy-pasta.