I am so freaking bored of Shadowbringer's story

[Zeonx]

im not a fan of alisae but wanting an underage character quote un quote a child character not only to die but die in a painfull way you have cleary shown me that you are 1 messed up individual.

You need to stop playing video games.
When you start believing that a video game is some how connected to real life it's time to hang up your controller and find another hobby.

So when a kid dies in video game like say tomb raider or let's see walking dead I could name more but are you suggesting those developers are sick also?

It's not real it's just to make people go damn that's unreal because it isn't real it's like a story in a book where a axe murder kills a camp full of kids but the front of the book says it's not based on a true story and no kids were harmed in this book.

then you go oh man the person is this or that sorry I just can't agree with you.

Because the same could be said for movies like jason friday the 13th or scream and other movies, in the end they are all fictional not real.

[Lauront]

She's not real. You realise that, right? She's also a teenager - which makes the context of my post very different to how it'd be if she happened to be younger than sixteen. It's pretty creepy that you'd accuse someone of being a horrible person just because they dislike a fictional character and want them to be killed off in a fictional universe! Though if I recall correctly, it's far from the first time that you've made such comments.

Given that Alisae actively tries to kill off other characters during the story, I don't see why she should be immune to the consequences of her actions.

To the extent that she is actively touring with the WoL as an adventurer, she should be at risk. It's not like she's some child being forced into all this - she is a mature enough teenager to make her own decisions and accept that there may be consequences to these, including death.

Funnily enough, I seldom see this defence come up when the topic is killing off Alphinaud.

Beyond that, I agree with Zeonx as well... they're just pixels in the end.

[Gula]

WOW. You guys bit into this troll sandwich for 23 pages?! The OP posted one message that was their opinion. A very unpopular opinion. How does this spawn 23 pages of discussion? Shadowbringers is the best story to ever grace an MMO. Nothing compares. You can stop posting here now.

That's the OF for you. You could make a thread on the WoL in a nappy and guaranteed someone would take it seriously.

[Avidria]

I'd rather they not kill of Alphinaud or Alisae, I like both of them lmao

Though possibly unpopular opinion... I'm glad they haven't killed off any more of the main scions. 2 was enough for me :P

[Jybril]

I'd rather they not kill of Alphinaud or Alisae, I like both of them lmao

Though possibly unpopular opinion... I'm glad they haven't killed off any more of the main scions. 2 was enough for me :P

The Scions as a whole have been wonderful. This expansion really helped them shine because they actually feel like they are our friends on a journey that actually help fight. It feels like we're never alone anymore. I use to hate them all lol.
It took so long for them to get to where they are now though. :/

[Tlamila]

The problem is that Yoshida himself has stated that they written her on purpose to be seen that way. (As in either friend or someone that is in love with the WoL) Ryne still feels more pure on that part because she does not show any kind of jealousy towards other people liking us which is shown quite a bit with Alisaie.

I am also not sure why they did that. I know younger people can fall in love with older ones, but in a game where they dont let us be teenager because they fear bad press if people use it for lewd stuff, I am a bit surprised that they made a clearly underage character into someone that can be easily seen as in love with us.

It sounds indeed very controversial.
And yeah, younger people can fall for older, for example, as a kid I had a crush on my sister's friend, who was 18, but sure as hell if it was returned it would have been creepy. The same way, I'd feel it equally creepy if the WoL had a thing for Alisae. Or for Alphinaud for that matter, since the WoL can be any gender and sexual orientation.

[Vahlnir]

It sounds indeed very controversial.
And yeah, younger people can fall for older, for example, as a kid I had a crush on my sister's friend, who was 18, but sure as hell if it was returned it would have been creepy. The same way, I'd feel it equally creepy if the WoL had a thing for Alisae. Or for Alphinaud for that matter, since the WoL can be any gender and sexual orientation.

Eh, there's a difference between having a crush and "fangirling". And to me, the latter is what Alisae does. The WoL is basically a celebrity. Heck, if I was in close proximity to a celebrity I like I would be pretty excited too, bordering on giddy. That doesn't mean I have a crush. It just means I really like that person and what they are associated with.

[NessaWyvern]

She's not real. You realise that, right? She's also a teenager - which makes the context of my post very different to how it'd be if she happened to be younger than sixteen. It's pretty creepy that you'd accuse someone of being a horrible person just because they dislike a fictional character and want them to be killed off in a fictional universe! Though if I recall correctly, it's far from the first time that you've made such comments.

Given that Alisae actively tries to kill off other characters during the story, I don't see why she should be immune to the consequences of her actions.

Exactly, almost everyone who played Skyrim wanted to kill those extremely annoying children, didn't make them horrible people.

[Vahlnir]

Exactly, almost everyone who played Skyrim wanted to kill those extremely annoying children, didn't make them horrible people.

"Another adventurer here to lick my father's boots. Good job..."

This kid had a lot of nerve.

[Stepjam]

Eh, there's a difference between having a crush and "fangirling". And to me, the latter is what Alisae does. The WoL is basically a celebrity. Heck, if I was in close proximity to a celebrity I like I would be pretty excited too, bordering on giddy. That doesn't mean I have a crush. It just means I really like that person and what they are associated with.

There is subtext that she is actually crushing on the WoL. Like when the girl she was working with at the start of ShB gives her a hard time by making a pass at your character.
It's just subtext so everyone can interpret the character how they wish to of course. Same with the exarch