% Meld Success Rate

[syntaxlies]

Perfect you answered both of your own concerns, add a new stat like concentration and put it on HQ'd gear/tools to help your materia %'s. Also you said it yourself

"thats only an animation we can assume that your tool is only prepping the item to receive the materia since they already said that you use the goggy tool to attach."

Excellent! you can improve your stats so that the item your prepping is in a better condition to receive the materia.

you forgot the part where i said

unattainable.

since you insist on defending your case to the bitter end here lemme ask you a question.

have have melded a grade 3 and now are trying a grade 4 you have no gear on at this point and the % is 18 success. With you super gear what do you think the % should be?

[Belial]

you forgot the part where i said

Seems you forgot some of the original posts in which a mock formula was already given.

Reading Comprehension <Can I Has It?>

[syntaxlies]

Seems you forgot some of the original posts in which a mock formula was already given.

Reading Comprehension <Can I Has It?>

i would rather it be answered in my way ty and im pretty sure the op was edited

[tachikoma]

i would rather it be answered in my way ty and im pretty sure the op was edited

For the reading impaired:

I'm sure they can put 20 minutes into balancing a formula to keep the current status as is with normal lvl proper gear and give a small boost to the people with materia/HQ gear, and a larger bonus to the people who have full forbiden HQ'd sets for crafting.

10 minute formula I came up with.

take current % numbers and add modifier's A and B:

Main hand stat(vit/str/dex/mnd/etc) for modifier A:
0-200: .8
201-250: .9
251-300: 1.0
301-350: 1.1
351+: 1.2

Sum of ( Control + Craftsmanship + magic.Craftsmanship) for modifier B:
0-200: .8
201-210: .9
211-220: 1.0
221-230: 1.1
231+: 1.2

ex: Weaver with 325-DEX and a sum of 235(control/crafts/m.crafts) doing a forbid with 20% success with new system would be: .2 * 1.1 * 1.2 => .264 or 26.4%

Since i'm sure I'll get nit picked over the #'s listed I did these at work from memory I would obviously put on proper gear and take a basic look at the stats etc on each job then do some quick melds to figure out proper #'s so that it is balanced.

[syntaxlies]

For the reading impaired:

or the people who did not re read the op after it was edited, funny how people resort to bashing when they've got no argument left.

[Belial]

i would rather it be answered in my way ty and im pretty sure the op was edited

Translation:
I don't understand math.

or the people who did not re read the op after it was edited, funny how people resort to bashing when they've got no argument left.

It wasn't part of the OP, it was several posts down. Not sure if trolling, or just stupid.

[syntaxlies]

Translation:
I don't understand math.

wow, you come into a thread and don't like someones opinion(who has not insulted anyone in anyway i might add) and start flaming them. what a unique approach to the FF forums.

[Belial]

wow, you come into a thread and don't like someones opinion(who has not insulted anyone in anyway i might add) and start flaming them. what a unique approach to the FF forums.

I have made no statement as to which side I support in this matter, so... no. You're wrong about liking or disliking opinions. It's pretty obvious that you don't have the ability to read points thoroughly as you ask for information to be repeated, in which case yea, I'm gonna have a little fun with ya. :O

[syntaxlies]

I have made no statement as to which side I support in this matter, so... no. You're wrong about liking or disliking opinions. It's pretty obvious that you don't have the ability to read points thoroughly as you ask for information to be repeated, in which case yea, I'm gonna have a little fun with ya. :O

as i said, the op was edited with that info.

but now that i have gone back and read the revised op ill add that going from 20% to 26% is insane. I wouldn't be in favor of anyhting over 1-2 %

[Tango]

since you insist on defending your case to the bitter end here lemme ask you a question.

have have melded a grade 3 and now are trying a grade 4 you have no gear on at this point and the % is 18 success. With you super gear what do you think the % should be?

Well besides that fact that 18% trying to attach a 4th materia is highly exaggerated (unless your going for gamblers crown and even then you're doing it wrong) and you fail to specify what 'super gear' is to you I don't think it should exceed 25%.