5.x General PvP and Feast Feedback Thread

[Divinemights]

I wonder what ladder would looks like right now when they are showing win-loss ratio again.

[Newmanxeno]

Make the medals glow very brightly when you press Pick Up the Medals.

[kensatsu]

A feedback about jobs :

Healer :

Healer are balanced, but whm is the better one, not by far, but still, (you have a burst, 10% damage debuff, and a bit more heal because of the regens skill off course).
Also Cure II, Benefic II ect... heal 4000 HP when a simple GCD from tank, ranged and melee is 4000 HP as well, i think its hard to deal against pressure as healer because of that.

Melee : Monk have powerfull burst, samurai and ninja is strong and have good burst, and dragoon... Why his dive CD is 45 sec ? its like he just do pressure and have weak burst.

Tank : All tank look alike but nascent flash from war is not intersting, its harder to use and don't heal more than the regen of Gunbreaker, it make nascent flash the weakest peel of all tank, this skill should be replaced or buffed

Ranged : DNC and SMN is strong, Bard and machinist is weak, why the bard don't have a burst on army's Peaon. RDM have an harder time when everyone have sprint its harder for ranged relying on casting, it's even more true for a BLM.
But i still think RDM and BLM is strong but need more training works than DNC and SMN.

For The balance sake i suggest this vision : Nerf somes jobs and buff others is a bad move, i mean : buff the weakest or Nerf the strongest but if you choose to do nerf and buff in the same times you get other balances issue.

[Divinemights]

Delete the feast

#deletethefeast
#8v8v8 competitive frontline?
Not sure if that works tho

[Astrophysx]

Glowing weapons for Wolf Collars. :3

[Nirokun]

As long as top 100 rewards exist in their current implementation most of Ranked Feast will just be Win Trading and Alts taking up most of the top 100 rewards. The system is incredibly toxic towards players that wish to obtain the rewards and more than skilled enough to but are unable to due to the large scale abuse of the system unintentional and intentionally. The fact they aren't even attainable by dps queues either.

I'm going to stop you right there. These just aren't true at all, like at all. You're just lying at this point and people who don't play Feast (who don't know better) might even believe you. The PVP community is small, and you recognize the players on the board. You see them in matches and you fight them, so you know them. There have been people suspected of cheating (buying wins, etc) but those people are shunned. It's simply not true to say that cheaters / alts take up the majority of the Top 100.

Also, ranged queues are tough. But I made Top 100 3 seasons (Season 1 / 5 / 8, each season I tried) on SMN (using healer in low level queues to speed through to higher matches where I needed my main job). You can make Top 100 on ranged, it's not impossible. I have a full time job and am married. I don't play all day. I queue'd after dinner on weekdays and over the weekend in the afternoons/evenings.

Please don't spread misinformation.

[EdgyLatinName]

Please stop removing abilities and then adding the same ones back in.

I know you guys like to do a big "revamp" of PvP every expansion, so please try to remember this post for future reference.

[Rubytoe]

For Sch I think indominabilty should have 3 charges.
I still feel like sch is at the bottom of the healers in feast.
The only thing I see good about sch right now is Biolysys + DRK's edge of shadow on a target for 40% reduction to hp recovered.

[BloodRubyXII]

I'm going to stop you right there. These just aren't true at all, like at all. You're just lying at this point and people who don't play Feast (who don't know better) might even believe you. The PVP community is small, and you recognize the players on the board. You see them in matches and you fight them, so you know them. There have been people suspected of cheating (buying wins, etc) but those people are shunned. It's simply not true to say that cheaters / alts take up the majority of the Top 100.

Also, ranged queues are tough. But I made Top 100 3 seasons (Season 1 / 5 / 8, each season I tried) on SMN (using healer in low level queues to speed through to higher matches where I needed my main job). You can make Top 100 on ranged, it's not impossible. I have a full time job and am married. I don't play all day. I queue'd after dinner on weekdays and over the weekend in the afternoons/evenings.

Please don't spread misinformation.

All of this, plus loads of people have been hoofed from Ladder for cheating/being boosted. And like Nirokun, both my top 100 seasons were played purely as Range, I think anyone on my DC can attest aside from S4 where I decided going Scholar seemed like a good idea after getting 1600 as SMN - I have never played on the ladder as anything else. Since S7 I've worked lates & nights, which limited heavily my ability to have time to play (because my late shift is 2PM-10PM ST, ergo covering the entire time span queues are active; you 9-5 guys have no idea how lucky you are). Also DPS queues were instant as melee for the majority of Stormblood, so it's clear you're just regurgitating negative information, Poppet, and have no idea what you're talking about.

[Saintly]

"Top 100 are win traders & alts" Excuse is getting old, can we please drop it, since those who claim that have not provided solid proof even once.

At this point is almost as lame as my other favorite excuse that keeps popping in the forums "X keeps undercutting me, he's using bots".