Quote Originally Posted by Saeno View Post
That seems to prioritize your spell casting then, also I imagine Confiteor would give 5 or 10 gauge. If you base it off of server ticks then i'd also attach oath generation to Royal authority and atonement. Maybe Goring blade as well.I'm not sure if this would just cause PLD to go overboard with gauge generation and make them a sheltron monster.
Why would you add all these abilities to the list? Including Confiteor? There's no reason to just throw all their abilities on the list of stuff that generates Oath. Also, the reason to go with spells (and just Holy Spirit/Circle) is two-fold:
1) You only need 20 Oath to make up the difference between server ticks and AA. If you look at doing it in 5 Oath chunks, in a given 21 GCD rotation, the only ability you only use 4 times is Holy Spirit/Circle. It fits. (I guess, you could just tag 20 Oath generation onto Confiteor and call it a day...)
2) Spells have a restriction to prevent unlimited spamming. MP. You can't just prioritize your spell casting. You need to do your weaponskill comboes to build your MP back up.

This keeps the overall Oath generation pretty much exactly where it's currently at, except you start fights at max Oath and also get Oath during downtime.