Dropped Items and Materia

[grandm]

i have said it a million times, i'll say it a million more. having the best gear does not make ppl say "there is no need to do content now i have the best gear"

you have the best gear in the game so now what?

A) stand in uldah doing nothing?
B)put your uber high stat gear to good use and go out and kill something, showing off your epicness to a group?

but anyway if you took materia out of the game you would still have the same situation. you have just finished off getting a full set of the best U/U gear in the game. would you stop doing dungeons and boss battles to stand in uldah. or would you take you great gear and do something with a group of friends, because doing something is better than standing around. doing something with the best gear on is better than doing nothing with the best gear on. ppl that say materia gear is so good there is no point in doing content, have problems of their own to overcome that are separate to FF14

[Brannigan]

i have said it a million times, i'll say it a million more. having the best gear does not make ppl say "there is no need to do content now i have the best gear"

you have the best gear in the game so now what?

A) stand in uldah doing nothing?
B)put your uber high stat gear to good use and go out and kill something, showing off your epicness to a group?

but anyway if you took materia out of the game you would still have the same situation. you have just finished off getting a full set of the best U/U gear in the game. would you stop doing dungeons and boss battles to stand in uldah. or would you take you great gear and do something with a group of friends, because doing something is better than standing around. doing something with the best gear on is better than doing nothing with the best gear on. ppl that say materia gear is so good there is no point in doing content, have problems of their own to overcome that are separate to FF14

If I have no item/quest/story/whatever incentive I'll probably do content a few times with my friends and then choose the option you failed to mention: play a different game. Items are what keep games like this going. I am certain that the developers know this since Yoshida has played games like EverQuest, etc. Dropped items are GOING to outclass crafted/materia eventually. Allowing U/U to meld materia would stop crafting from becoming useless.


I'd also like to mention that while forbidden materia is cool on paper, in practice it's kind of dumb and completely dependent on chance. I think the system would be better and allow for more interesting items if every item just had a set number of slots.

For example a Cobalt Winglet might have a single Tier IV slot while a Cobalt Shamshir might have two Tier IIIs and Ifrit's Blade has a IV and a III.

[Reokudo]

If I have no item/quest/story/whatever incentive I'll probably do content a few times with my friends and then choose the option you failed to mention: play a different game. Items are what keep games like this going. I am certain that the developers know this since Yoshida has played games like EverQuest, etc. Dropped items are GOING to outclass crafted/materia eventually. Allowing U/U to meld materia would stop crafting from becoming useless.


I'd also like to mention that while forbidden materia is cool on paper, in practice it's kind of dumb and completely dependent on chance. I think the system would be better and allow for more interesting items if every item just had a set number of slots.

For example a Cobalt Winglet might have a single Tier IV slot while a Cobalt Shamshir might have two Tier IIIs and Ifrit's Blade has a IV and a III.

This would be awesome.

[Jynx]

you have the best gear in the game so now what?

A) stand in uldah doing nothing?
B)put your uber high stat gear to good use and go out and kill something, showing off your epicness to a group?

You would be amazed at how quickly the novelty of having amazing and rare gear wears off. Many hardcore FFXI players quit not long after reaching the epic status of "Dude who has a relic weapon" Without a purpose or sensed of progression people get bored rather quickly.

Having a great community is one of the ways to combat this as many people stuck around XI just for the people they knew and the sense of community the game had.

Unfortunatly I feel cross-server mingling will kill the sense of a server community IMHO.