Quote Originally Posted by Anesteria View Post
No they can't Physic. ....



let me try to make it more mathematical.

according to Yoshida, in november


Limited Job= Job whose design or concept does not mesh with normal ffxiv job/class/role/combat design.



so, using the logical law of substitution
Substitution is a fundamental concept in logic. A substitution is a syntactic transformation on formal expressions. To apply a substitution to an expression means to consistently replace its variable, or placeholder, symbols by other expressions. The resulting expression is called a substitution instance, or short instance, of the original expression.


Would people have been upset if Blue mage was not a limited Job.


subsititute


would people have been upset if Blue mage was not a Job whose design or concept does not mesh with normal ffxiv job/class/role/combat design.

And the answer is yes, because we have ALREADY seen people mad that existing jobs were changed to fit the overall framework of FFXIV design.




now, you personally believe Yoshida is incorrect, and blue mage can be put into a ffxiv framework with no appreciable loss. OR you believe that such loss would be acceptable based on what sacrifices might be made the other way. That is a fair opinion to have. But it is an opinion, not a logical truism, or universally accepted concept.


My entire beef with your opinion, is you seem to not understand it is an opinion, it is not a fact, the things you state as facts are not facts, they are guesses, suppositions, hopes, and fears.


Your premise is Yoshida willfully sought to keep an awesome perfect ffxiv blue mage concept from players. Why? what would he gain by doing so? Is it possible that he believed that this iteration of blue mage was truer to what blue mage is about? Which is more likely.