What we have here is a problem with how people present their ideas.

Just because someone genuinely likes a feature doesn't mean they are white-knighting, and just because someone is unhappy with a features doesn't mean they are dark-knighting.

"ZOMG THIS SUCKS SE RUINED THE GAME AGAIN" is not the right way to about a complaint, because it doesn't offer any constructive feedback. Also, any post involving "it ruined the game" "it's going to kill the game" "nobody will use this" blah blah blah is purely a personal opinion and does nothing for actual feedback purposes.

<insert made up percentage here> of the complaints on the forums would probably have been taken more seriously if they were presented in a way that didn't make the OP look like a complete tool.