Please no more Eureka!

[Voltyblast]

Other alternatives are also a waste of time, considering the short lifespan of very item in the game. Even Savage reward are clearly not valuable enough since they are only slightly better than what you can obtain by simply doing your roulette.

But Savage rewards are clearly valuable enough to diminish the relic value by delaying it by 1-2 months, as you clearly stated?

That's the thing, they've stated that delaying the Relic weapon was intentional since the first Anima step as to not diminish the value of the Savage weapon.
Yet people still believe that it's supposed to be the competitive casual weapon when it hasn't been for years, and use that assumption to claim that they were wronged because Eureka was not the casual content they fantasized.

So which is it? Are they valuable or not?

I've spent years in FFXI, so I know what horizontal progression means. This game is not suited for that, and probably never will. You can't have horizontal progresson when you have a mathematical best stuff, only stuff that you aren't able to obtain.

How do you know that it wouldn't work here? Until they actually bother trying it we will never know for sure and your only reasoning is that "it's not suited for that" and "you have mathematical better stuff" without some proof? Does it really take a lot to insert more than 2 options of weapons and armors? Again this is the only thing I cannot comment because I don't have experience with ff11 but you're not even going to tell me WHY it wouldn't work here, so you're as clueless as I am whether horizontal progression could work or not.

Criticism is not. "Wa wa wa, delete Eureka because I don't like it" is. Especially when people claim facts based on nothing like how the whole playerbase don't like Eureka.

Then define criticism or something? Because I can probably look at the forum and on the internet for many discussions about how to improve eureka with legitimate good reasons for such changes. Are those criticism or trolling? And so what if I don't like it? I'm a troll for disliking it? And if you're absolutely sure of the player base liking eureka then, by all means, show me some proof: by your logic finding people who liked it should be easy, since the large majority seem to like it and only a vocal minority doesn't.

What ? Did you actually follow some Eureka hate threads before ? Didn't you see the number of "braindead" and "white knight" comments directed at those who liked Eureka ? Here's an example :

Tell me again how this is "criticism"

So just because some JERKS are actual trolling others for actually liking it, ALL OF US who don't like eureka are suddenly jerks too? That's so closeminded my head is imploding.

I'm not bashing you for liking Eureka (I have friends who like eureka and I don't bash them: are you going to tell me that I should?). I'm bashing you because you keep missing the point and white knighting way above normal levels about the fact that many people have made legitimately good points on improving eureka (like the synch that many were hoping for and more) and yet they don't even bother listening to negative feedback and only to positive, "because everything works fine". Many have said that Eureka has potential if done right but it isn't, many have said that it's fine to put Eureka if it didn't have relic behind it or more content. But just because you see haters and trolls picking on those who like it you just automatically assume we're all like this? I don't even know how to say but this is really dishonest from you.

I can only reply with my own post from before

Are there trolls here? Yes, there are, but I'm not one of them

Have a good day and I hope you enjoy Eureka in the future. I definitely won't but I know others will, and if it's true that the majority truly likes it then I'll just move and leave: you get to keep your Eureka - which you claim to be a huge success - and we get to play better games.

Just make sure you weren't wrong with that, or you'll get an even emptier expansion next year!