1.0 Minfilia, before the Calamity expanded her bust size in direct relation to a reduction in intelligence ("What do you mean Minfilia that we can't use the Echo whenever we want? You yourself taught me how to do just that five years ago!!"). And when she had mundane but tasteful fashion sense, not that... thing she wore in ARR that was designed specifically to flaunt her chest and rear... *rolls eyes*

And I don't hate Lyse in more that I thought it was a cop-out revealing Yda as long dead and that Lyse was masquerading as her, it virtually invalidated everything that she did even back in 1.0. It just came across as SE simply weren't sure what to do with her and Papalymo anymore. Which is a shame as they were the first characters in FFXIV I ever met (as they appeared right at the start of the 1.0 Gridania story) and so I felt more closer to them than any other npc in the game.