Is Esuna Necessary As A Role Action?

[Gemina]

Issue with that is it has a 60-second cooldown. Not efficient for people getting debuffs within that cooldown window. But Esuna was barely needed for sub-40 content regardless, especially now with the blatant over-gearing. It’s more needed for things that have hard-ticking Poison DoTs, Paralysis, or Doom mechanics.

Also the Heavy status. Can't blame your mates for taking avoidable AoE if this is not being cleansed. The reduction to movement is drastic.

Cutters Cry is one early instance I can think of where Esuna is still needed to this day. Chimera is the first boss I can recall that uses non-telegraphed attacks that hit like a truck and also inflict a status ailment. At least one player gets nailed by Dragon/Ram's voice every time I go there, every time they go off. This is also a specific instance I can think of pre-SB that drove me crazy when I was leveling my SCH because I was below level 40 (the previous requirement for Leeches).

I want to say that it isn't until 50+ where the lack of a cleanse can lead to a player KO. Sastasha HM is one that immediately pops in mind.

[Ilyrian]

Cutters Cry is one early instance I can think of where Esuna is still needed to this day. Chimera is the first boss I can recall that uses non-telegraphed attacks that hit like a truck and also inflict a status ailment. At least one player gets nailed by Dragon/Ram's voice every time I go there, every time they go off. This is also a specific instance I can think of pre-SB that drove me crazy when I was leveling my SCH because I was below level 40 (the previous requirement for Leeches).
astasha HM is one that immediately pops in mind.

It's the Sandworm boss that's the first test of Esuna - that debuff is strong on undergeared/new players - and I've yet to see a new healer cope without it being Esuna'd off.

Edit: I maintain that is should just be baseline for all healers - it's crazy having it as an optional skill. It's the same as just removing all debuffs from the game - if healers have to know they need it, what is the point of having anything situational in the first place?
It is a terrible example to set to a new healer faced with these encounters not having it to hand. Watching people die to Doom in Dun Scaith and Exdeath - when it should be hardwired into the play style by that point is crazy. It's not like this game asks that much of healers in the general content anyway.

Role Actions were a terrible idea - but it's even more pronounced with healers. I want to have Rescue. The SB trailer said I could have it - and i can't. Crazy bad design.

[Gemina]

It's the Sandworm boss that's the first test of Esuna - that debuff is strong on undergeared/new players - and I've yet to see a new healer cope without it being Esuna'd off.

Edit: I maintain that is should just be baseline for all healers - it's crazy having it as an optional skill. It's the same as just removing all debuffs from the game - if healers have to know they need it, what is the point of having anything situational in the first place?
It is a terrible example to set to a new healer faced with these encounters not having it to hand. Watching people die to Doom in Dun Scaith and Exdeath - when it should be hardwired into the play style by that point is crazy. It's not like this game asks that much of healers in the general content anyway.

Role Actions were a terrible idea - but it's even more pronounced with healers. I want to have Rescue. The SB trailer said I could have it - and i can't. Crazy bad design.

The most trouble I've had with the sandworm boss in that instance are peeps running in the same path the worm is going, which acts like a ridiculous DoT; and standing in its AoE zone when it immerges, which I believe is also non-telegraphed iirc. You are right though, and this boss tends to cause a bit of trouble for new players.

I couldn't agree more about Esuna having no place in role skills. Having it as an innate skill for all healers should be a given. Role skills are such an oddity. Some of them make sense, others not so much. Healers really do seem to have gotten short end of the stick here. It needs a complete overhaul, but not necessarily taken out of the game. I like having to choose between Rescue and Cleric Stance. I do not like having to choose between Rescue and Esuna, if that makes sense.

[Mesarthim]

Before going to bed I decided to read up on the latest live letter summary.

10 role slots. HOPEFULLY this will fix the problem to some degree. I've been an advocate of "Esuna should never have been made optional" ever since 4.0, especially with how inconsistent status effects are in this game. Stormblood's role system has annoyed me to no end for both tanks and healers (mostly healers).

[CorbinDallas]

I rarely slot esuna, ever. Only if I'm running deep dungeons or fights that absolutely require it. Most debuffs aren't punishing enough to warrant taking it over others.

Surecast is insanely good right now and not enough people give it the credit it deserves. Aside from being fantastic in the current raid tier (5/7/8), it can be used practically everywhere there are knockbacks. The most recent example is Famfrit's Tsunami ability in Ridorana. Add to the fact it only has a 30s cooldown now, I have it on my bar pretty much all the time.

Protect needs deleting or reworked into the PvP version, frankly.

[Duskane]

well live letter confirmed at there will be one extra role slot so shouldn't be much issue to pack esuna now

[Kalinas]

I really hope that means come 5.0 we will just get old spells back finally and an over haul to the others in role actions

[ChiiSoSeriouz]

I’m not sure if this has been posted before, but Esuna doesn’t feel right to me being a role action.

I made a post awhile back regarding esuna

http://forum.square-enix.com/ffxiv/t...s-role-actions

[Sylvain]

With the 10 roles action
Two possibilities will open up

1- they don't know what to do so they allow us to have all 10 role action qkills

2- they added a ton of new skills and with 10 slots filler skills less esuna don't feel like a waste ( not as much)

I really hope it's the second option.