Why Eureka is a worse form of the Diadem IMO

[Reynhart]

One problem with this statement, is whether I AFK and hit Scatter over and over again, or top DPS, I still get the same reward.

In Eureka, if you AFK for most of the time or if you actively participate in targeting appropriate monsters, you get a very different reward. So, it should encourage people to do a little more effort.

Don't put words in my mouth, especially when you completely miss my point.

Problem is, you exactly said "I got reward, so I'm doing good" in a game that chose to not punish players but simply offers better reward if you do better. Because if the game punished you, then people would whine endlessly that "it's too haaard".

I gave you example of games that, in my opinion, did things right.

Examples that have absolutely no chance of being copied in this game. Seriously, anything remotely challenging is nerfed to the ground, do you really expect XIV taking inspiration from MH or Dark Soul ? Especially for the relic stuff, which we fully known would be tied to Eureka and fully known that it wouldn't involve challenging content.