Revelations from Patch 4.3

[Alleo]

About Yotsuyu:

I think that at least Maxima had believed that he was truly going there to make peace with Doma. Asahi needed Yotsuyu for destroying the plan because she was seen as someone from Doma thanks to her memory loss. Thus her standing there and talking about how she will rule Doma and then turning into a primal can be seen as a break of the contract because she was still seen as part of that country. Thankfully Asahi died and Maxima turned out to be truly someone from the other faction and someone that has a brain and saw that this was a set up to break peace again. In the end Yotsuyu was the most important part in the plan because if she had not turned then Asahi would not have anything that shows a break in contract. So in that way if his plan had gotten through Yotsuyu would have been partly responsible for another war and tension for Doma.

Also I still believe that this was Yotsuyu. I mean Tsuyu with no memories was like a child. Would a child really be able to fool everyone around her and then break out again to kill herself? Would the innocent Tsuyu really be able to act in her old ways? For me this was a sign that Yotsuyu has returned but as the primal shows she has a inner conflict. Because maybe for the first time in her life she (or more Tsuyu) was loved. Maybe that just completely broke her because that would mean that she finally had to face the consequences of her horrible actions. Maybe she cant just tell herself that her behaviour is justified? Thus her trying to kill herself.

I believe that she is quite aware that as soon as anyone sees that her memories are back she would get killed or sent back to Garlemald (and who knows what they would do to her). She was only alive because she had no memories and thus they did not want to judge her. Having them back makes her also able to be jugded and no matter if she behaved childlike for a time or maybe regret it a bit, she still did horrible stuff which would probably end in a death sentence. And with her memories back none of the people in Doma would probably even want her around.

In the end for me this was the best outcome. It may give Hien the motivation to make Doma in a better place (but realistically bad stuff will always happen, that just how it is), Gosetsu will go around and atone for the stuff he did under command and the people are finally able to heal their wounds without fearing that her memories might come back and thus they get punished again. And for Yotsuyu, well it might sound a bit strange but this might have been the best outcome for her too. She may have had a chance to live as Tsuyu but I am not sure if that would have been something forever. Where would she live? Would she be confined to one place her whole life because people would maybe just take their revenge out on her? Or maybe need to stay with guards thanks to the possibility of getting her memories back. Gosetsu is also old and wont always be around to protect her. Tsuyu was her only chance but I am honestly not sure if this was a great life either.

As Yotsuyu herself she would have either be killed or land in prison for the rest of her life where she will have to face the stuff she had done. There was no realistic way that she would have been able to go outside. So her being able to take down these three people and then being death while still at least having an understanding on what she did was probably the perfect way to end her arc. And its also a good way where I can accept the last few patches about her.

[Iscah]

..........

In the end Yotsuyu was the most important part in the plan because if she had not turned then Asahi would not have anything that shows a break in contract. So in that way if his plan had gotten through Yotsuyu would have been partly responsible for another war and tension for Doma.

I'm not quite following your logic there - I'm not sure what war has been averted. If you're thinking it's because Asahi's death allowed Maxima to step in and properly complete the peace contract, that probably didn't help much in the end. As I said before, I don't believe the Garleans ever intended to uphold it. (I don't even know if Varis was aware of it or if it's purely Elidibus's work.)

THAT SAID, I think you may be right with a lot of the other things.

There's one moment that I think gets overlooked in light of all that happens afterwards - in Namai, when she starts having flashbacks, cries out in horror that the things she's been remembering are all true, and begs for forgiveness. I think this may be one of the few moments where she shows her true feelings - but also she may realise after this that she has admitted in front of the others that she does remember (not that she's been hiding it before, rather that she didn't understand it yet), and realises that she may have sealed her fate by doing so.

[Alleo]

..........

I'm not quite following your logic there - I'm not sure what war has been averted. If you're thinking it's because Asahi's death allowed Maxima to step in and properly complete the peace contract, that probably didn't help much in the end. As I said before, I don't believe the Garleans ever intended to uphold it. (I don't even know if Varis was aware of it or if it's purely Elidibus's work.)

THAT SAID, I think you may be right with a lot of the other things.

There's one moment that I think gets overlooked in light of all that happens afterwards - in Namai, when she starts having flashbacks, cries out in horror that the things she's been remembering are all true, and begs for forgiveness. I think this may be one of the few moments where she shows her true feelings - but also she may realise after this that she has admitted in front of the others that she does remember (not that she's been hiding it before, rather that she didn't understand it yet), and realises that she may have sealed her fate by doing so.

About MSQ:

If Asahi did not die by her hands, he might have still died on the way back (because Varis cant know if he is on the ship or not) but Alphinaud would not have gone back with them and who knows if Maxima would have survived it. Thus Varis could spread his message about the "savages" needing to be put under their control, thus the factions that wants peace would have lost influence. (And we also dont know how high Maxima stands in this faction) So Varis getting more people on his side might have just created another conflict with Doma, while right now the one that now is in charge of peace is still alive and will be back to Garlemald thus their faction still have a chance.

I am not sure if she completely remembers everything in Namai (as in everything done to the people of Doma) or just that one scene. She still kinda acts way more childlike unlike after what happens with her parents. Also she remembered even more when she met them. (I am also not 100% sure if she says in german that she remembers everything. For me at least that scene was more about Tsuyu realizing that she did something bad and maybe a few scenes to that and apologies for something that she still does not fully understand. (She is shaken up by those memories which kinda implies to me that she is still not fully her, while later she is probably more shaken up by feeling guilty thanks to the positive feelings she got from Gosetsu.) But thats all speculating. Its kinda interesting how you can interpret it in so many different views and I did like the MSQ quite a lot.

[Remedi]

About MSQ:

If Asahi did not die by her hands, he might have still died on the way back (because Varis cant know if he is on the ship or not) but Alphinaud would not have gone back with them and who knows if Maxima would have survived it. Thus Varis could spread his message about the "savages" needing to be put under their control, thus the factions that wants peace would have lost influence. (And we also dont know how high Maxima stands in this faction) So Varis getting more people on his side might have just created another conflict with Doma, while right now the one that now is in charge of peace is still alive and will be back to Garlemald thus their faction still have a chance.

I am not sure if she completely remembers everything in Namai (as in everything done to the people of Doma) or just that one scene. She still kinda acts way more childlike unlike after what happens with her parents. Also she remembered even more when she met them. (I am also not 100% sure if she says in german that she remembers everything. For me at least that scene was more about Tsuyu realizing that she did something bad and maybe a few scenes to that and apologies for something that she still does not fully understand. (She is shaken up by those memories which kinda implies to me that she is still not fully her, while later she is probably more shaken up by feeling guilty thanks to the positive feelings she got from Gosetsu.) But thats all speculating. Its kinda interesting how you can interpret it in so many different views and I did like the MSQ quite a lot.

Went back to watch the cutscenes again about tsuyu

I'm inclined to say that Yotsuyu came back completely after the meeting with her forster parents, but her staying with Gosetsu had an effect on her, in ENG she says if only she didn't remember and wonders why Gosetsy doesn't hate her, she doesn't speak his name so I'm just assuming it's him, because on their relationship during 4.0. I think in a way that she reminds of herself and how she was stepped on by others and while she choose vengeance and hate, he choose compassion and kindness. This is why he appears in the adds phase or so I believe it is from what I can gather. It's possible we won't never be able to know for sure 100%, because there's a bit of out of character for her. I suppose they wanted to play a bit with it, the facxt that beside the initial scene we don't have a Yotsuyu and Gosetsu scene again makes things hazy in my opinion. .