New alliance loot rules discussion

[Mahrze]

It depends entirely on if anyone else in the party is gearing a tank or not.

You're basically using whataboutism as a way to say this has merit.

Camp A (current): Best geared job = best chance to be clearing catch up content, so everyone gets "fair chances" cuz "effort"
Camp B (previous): play job you want to gear = lower chance of clear due to potential learning curve hazard, a good chance to "need" what you, y'know, need.

If you really want to preach a "fair" solution, they should have made each chest give tokens like raids have done since HW. While having this greed option,
"Ivalician Token A" 2 for: head, gloves, shoes.
"Ivalician Token B" 4 for: top, bottom.

This way: anyone can play as whatever AND have equal roll privileges. Who knew?

[TaiyoShikasu]

snip

The logic of Camp A makes no sense because alliance raids are casual content which given the disaster even Crystal Tower raids can be, some people treat them as more casual than dungeons.

Going in with your i370 means nothing when gear literally does not matter when there's no enrage timer to beat and you have two hours to clear the content. Not to mention mechanics are what get people killed in them, not something that makes gear matter and having a high item level doesn't mean anything if you fail mechanics.