SE Needs to Auto-disband FCs

[HyoMinPark]

So why should they be allowed to drop below 4 players in the first place?

Both pieces of information indicate that the minimum FC size should be 4.

And? Requirements to personal housing purchases also state that you have to be Second Lieutenant in your current Grand Company AND be level 50. Are you going to propose we add those restrictions to FC formations as well because they’re present for Housing?

The requirements state that you need 4 members to form an FC, yes. But nowhere in them do they state you have to maintain such a minimum. What if one of the 4 players decides to quit the game and deletes their character? Or they have a falling out with one of the other individuals in the FC? Should the FC as a whole be punished and forcibly disbanded if one decided to quit, or if two get into an argument and one leaves? No. That’s silly. Why do you care if FCs drop below 4 members? What sort of burden does it place on you, or the playerbase as a whole? You make this proposition, but you give no reasoning to back them up.

“Why should they be allowed to drop below 4 members in the first place”? Why should they be forced to maintain a minimum member count in the first place?

Why are you bringing in unrelated issues? Please leave your emotional baggage in the other thread.

Your propositions in this thread are directly related to Housing, which you were discussing in your other thread. These two threads are related, whether you want to openly acknowledge that or not. If this thread was related just to FCs with sub-four members, and not Housing at all in any shape or fashion, you wouldn’t be citing Housing requirements in your OP. And, if it’s not related to Housing, then again: why do you care if an FC drops below 4 members or not? An FC with 3 members can’t purchase a house anyways, so why do you care if it exists as it is?

You should probably also learn what “emotional baggage” actually means; you’re the only one getting overly heated, hostile, and defensive in your own threads, not me.

[NephthysVasudan]

<snip>

Actually the OP is right...your derailing the thread and resorting to personal attacks...I suggest you stop before I report you myself.

Knock it off.

As for the OP's proposal....I dont like it either...but lets stop with the stupid foolishness of name calling as you so pointedly indicated and drawing out topics that are not in this thread.
Nowhere did I see mention of housing in any case...the complaint is FC's shouldn't be so easily formed...nothing to do with housing.
Wasn't there in the first place until you started making it an issue. Goes for everyone else who also drew a conclusion...coincidental or not.

[Bourne_Endeavor]

Would it kill you to stay on topic and not resort to personal attacks?

Actually the OP is right...your derailing the thread and resorting to personal attacks...I suggest you stop before I report you myself.

Knock it off.

What? No, seriously. What?

In what insane reality do either of you live in that any response Hyomin made constitutes a personal attack? I was under the impression this were a forum where people... disagreed with one another. Apparently, doing so equals to emotional baggage. Given the OP's increasing hostility, what's actual quite apparent is they do not want to have any discussion but simply expect everyone to agree with their proposal. Such a shame the world doesn't revolve around you.

Anyway.

As nearly everyone has already stated, enforcing a four person restriction on FCs serves no objective purpose but to punish people. You even acknowledge alts would circumvent such a restriction regardless, OP; making it all the more pointless. If people wish to have a FC with only one or two member, leave them be. They neither hurt nor impact you.