so whens Alphinaud gonna die or sent offscreen for a long time?

[TouchandFeel]

That's also not accurate.
Identical implies they are the same, can't be the same while being different genders. It's purely happen stance that fraternal twins look alike.

........... Male and female twins cannot be identical............. Why do you not know this?

It is possible for identical twins to be of opposite sexes it is just beyond incredibly rare and would require a chromosomal anomaly within the egg being fertilized in which it would have an extra X chromosome. Since identical twins are defined by being monozygotic, the zygote (i.e. fertilized egg) formed from an abnormal egg with an extra X chromosomes would have XXY chromosomes which could in turn split to form the twin zygotes, one retaining the XX chromosomes and the other the XY, which would result in identical twins of different sexes.

[Tlamila]

Fair enough. But personally Alisae's facial features seem a bit more rounded while Alphinauld's seem more sharper, but perhaps that's me trying to see a difference that isn't there.

I see the same, her face is quite different from his, and I think you're right it's that it's more rounded. You can tell them apart easily even with identical clothes.

[Stormfur]

I wish that we could influence the storyline more than we do right now. If I had my way, Alphinaud would be relegated to being the Scion bean-counter that he's always secretly longed to be, and Raubahn or Merlyb or Kan-E would be leading the charge.

[Melichoir]

Theyre both still somewhat young, so theyre likely to look semi similar. As they grow up, differences will become more pronounced.


All that said, I like Alphinaud. Hes growing on me. Unlike minfillia, which was nothing more than a pretty face who had no agency, Alphinaud is actually a character who does things, messes it up, learns, adn then does more things. Hes actually somewhat interesting, if not a little stuffy.

[The_Promised]

Hate him and his arrogant sister. I'm happy with Nero and Zenos. The Empire have the best npcs. Lyse is all arrogant with Fordola too. For me they can kill Lyse and we stay with Fordola as our friend and waifu. There is a cutscene that I laugh hard when we kill a mob and than Lyse appears on the fight pose asking if the warrior of light (us) was alright. When we going take the spots on this game and not the npcs? I wanna Yugiri on the holophotes.

[Bahati]

While I would love to see more Alisae, I'm not about to sacrifice Alphy time for Lyse time. That girl is something else and is pretty silly IMHO.

[Melichoir]

While I would love to see more Alisae, I'm not about to sacrifice Alphy time for Lyse time. That girl is something else and is pretty silly IMHO.

'Yda' was more likeable than Lyse. Cause they took her character and tried to make her this tragic heroine whos all tough as nails serious and no nonsense. It flattened her out, and then stuck her in somewhat absurd settings. You cant write a character one way then do a 180 and expect us not to think its strange. Shes got more agency than Minfillia, but now shes just annoying af and boring to interact with.

[basketofseals]

Hraesvelgr calls her delusional and says that the Shiva she's created is not the actual Shiva. He doesn't say she's tempered herself.

Ah, well I certainly don't have any screen shots of a MSQ I did years ago, but from what I remember he definitely mentioned that her summoning Shiva into herself either warped or changed her mind and or memories.

Ysayle was DEFINITELY brought up in the most recent MSQ though in regards the treatment of tempered individuals, so at the very least, the cast considers her as such.

[Tlamila]

'Yda' was more likeable than Lyse. Cause they took her character and tried to make her this tragic heroine whos all tough as nails serious and no nonsense. It flattened her out, and then stuck her in somewhat absurd settings. You cant write a character one way then do a 180 and expect us not to think its strange. Shes got more agency than Minfillia, but now shes just annoying af and boring to interact with.

Worked the opposite for me instead. I couldn't stand "Yda", I found her irritating beyond measure and completely braindead. Completely out of place in a group of intellectuals too. I was very happy when the unmasking happened and she showed to be an actual person with a brain, a personality, goals etc, and not just a dumb sidekick for Papalaymo.

[Missbone]

I hope they get rid of this alpguy and his sither (or is it brother?)eee very soon, i absolut hate him. He ruined most of the Cutscenes in HW and Stormblood for me so far. I skip every cutscenes where he appears, sadly there are only very few without him. I also hoped that ysholda and the others got more screentime but nope..